594 Comments
User's avatar
Zhivko Yakimov's avatar

This increasingly looks like a pretext to fire some people and later hire new ones, but with the right ideological mindset. As someone born and raised in Eastern Europe, I have seen this going on for more than 30 years, and you folks start looking increasingly like us (and that is not a compliment).

I expect a few months down the line, they will say that they actually need more people, and then argue that the new hires will be much better than the old one. Everything else is a circus to divert attention, and it appears to be working.

Expand full comment
GJ Loft ME CA FL IL NE CT MI's avatar

I'm really surprised that Krugman hasn't pointed out the 4 Medicare/Medicaid fraudsters that Trump pardoned on 1/20/2021. They bilked us out of a combined $2 billion and change.

And then there's also the Medicare/Medicaid Senator from Florida - Rick Scott. The records are sealed but rumor has it that he stole several hundred million from Medicare/Medicaid. And Matt Gaetz's daddy did the same thing.

Expand full comment
Ethereal fairy Natalie's avatar

Well said, I came here to make those same observations! Not too many know about Daddy Gaetz because he sold the company just before the investigation, and turned the skimmed money into real estate.

Expand full comment
CampSwampy's avatar

Thanks for posting!

Expand full comment
User's avatar
Comment removed
Feb 13
Comment removed
Expand full comment
Bill Katz's avatar

That musical Coda this morning? They look like dudes but they aren’t. Which brings to mind which are fake ladies and which are real ladies. Same with Musk. And he brings to mind that someone needs to take Elon out to dinner — if ya know what I mean.

Another observation: it seems that Paul attracts a majority of men while Joyce Vance and Heather Cox attracts mostly women. Interesting isn’t it.

Expand full comment
Marsha Lieberman's avatar

Another observation, not really true (said a woman who reads all of them).

Expand full comment
ErisX's avatar

Hear hear! Lots of women read Paul's work. Here's another one.

Expand full comment
Carol Wasteneys's avatar

I am a woman

Expand full comment
Ethereal fairy Natalie's avatar

Yes! hello, I read them, and Robert Reich.

Expand full comment
Stuart's avatar

Ditto, ditto. I'm a cis white male, age 69, who reads Krugman and Richardson every day, and Joyce Vance whenever she's brought to my attention.

Expand full comment
SophieM's avatar

Same.

Expand full comment
BTAM Master's avatar

Do you have any data to back up your observation? Fox news also uses wiggle words to plant a suggestion while saying nothing: "Observation" "Seems" "Interesting isn’t it"

Expand full comment
LarryG's avatar

"many people are saying... "

Expand full comment
Andrew's avatar

My personal favorite, it's an easy Trump tell that a lie is coming.

Expand full comment
Digispeaker's avatar

Just looking for attention - again.

Expand full comment
Digispeaker's avatar

What a ridiculous uninformed observation.

Expand full comment
Leigh Horne's avatar

What's up with you, 'dude'? Something about your observations smells rotten to me. If I'm wrong, please explain.

Expand full comment
User's avatar
Comment removed
Feb 13
Comment removed
Expand full comment
Essmeier's avatar

...or anyone else, it would appear.

Expand full comment
M Randall's avatar

Inference from imputed gender of commenter avatars is shaky logic, to be polite. Let alone that those who comment are a self-selected group, maybe not a statistically valid representation of the columns readership.

Expand full comment
Barbara's avatar

Yet another woman who reads two of them and others. This is tangential anyway, possibly to troll women.

Expand full comment
Steven A.'s avatar

Are your first two initials RR?

Expand full comment
Andrew's avatar

This dude - I recognize him from my days reading NY MAG comments, he's a notorious troll who uses multiple identities (at least there he did) and was - if I recall correctly - blocked or removed multiple times but kept reappearing like a pustulent boil that just won't go away. The 4th grade repeating what you say back to you are his trademark, as well as one word replies like "gibberish." I'm sure I'll get some pithy reply to this.

Expand full comment
Laurence's avatar

They were. The posts on his timeline are identical to when that was his pseudonym just a couple of days ago. He changed it in the meantime.

Expand full comment
WinstonSmithLondonOceania's avatar

The Purge Pretext. No question about it. It's right there in Project 2025.

Is obeisance an ideology? Kleptocracy might loosely be called an "ideology", but I think that's debatable.

Expand full comment
Stephen Brady's avatar

I still can't help but wonder what hold Musk has on The Orange One? tRump is brash and obnoxious - a noisy con man, so what is keeping him sitting at the desk while a 3 year old picks his nose next to him... after all, he worries how he appears on TV and about his ratings. I remember a similar image of him in Helsinki with Vlad gloating next to him...

Expand full comment
Michael's avatar

Trump is for sale to the highest bidder. In 2016 it was Putin. Now it's Musk. Having been bought and paid for Trump has to show complete deference to his owners.

Expand full comment
Kit Harbison's avatar

I’m looking forward to the day that Trump’s lifestyle finally catches up to him and he has a stroke or cardiac event.

Expand full comment
Leigh Horne's avatar

I feel a bit creepy myself (maybe all the Trumpmusk slime has rubbed off on me) but I find myself wishing the same. However, unlike them, I wouldn't take pleasure in anyone's suffering, or use that to prove to myself how clever and special I am. I just want them gone.

Expand full comment
Lee Peters's avatar

Trump and Musk could disappear immediately but the problem would remain because 77 million Americans share their world view, and another 90 million aren’t offended enough to vote.

Expand full comment
The Coke Brothers's avatar

they don't have to suffer; it can be quick and painless (?)

Expand full comment
ErisX's avatar

Well see, I'm the opposite. I don't want them dead. I want them to understand things from my point of view, to really feel how much suffering they're causing, and to care about it. Is that so much to ask?

Expand full comment
Tom Hudak's avatar

I'd be happy if it were a permanent case of laryngitis, if there were such a thing.

Expand full comment
Ethereal fairy Natalie's avatar

That reminds of the saying "Everyone brings joy. Some when they arrive, and some when they go."

Expand full comment
Rainer Dynszis's avatar

I'm not sure about the cause of death. I hear that people with Trump's lifestyle get strangled by someone named Narcissus.

Expand full comment
Linda's avatar

Lol, love this. Narcissus drowned looking at himself in a pool of water I think. I could be wrong. It's been a hot minute since school.

Expand full comment
George Carty's avatar

Putin doesn't go in much for bribery as a means to control people, as a bribed person is always free to turn on their paymaster (either out of conscience or out of greed).

He prefers blackmail, and the fact that former girls from Jeffrey Epstein's island have accused Trump of raping them may well be key (along the fact that most of Putin's male fifth columnists in the West have form for sexual harassment).

Expand full comment
Michael's avatar

I think Putin is flexible. Bribes, blackmail, threats - whatever gets the job done. Trump is addicted to his luxurious lifestyle which in 2016 and before was apparently bankrolled by Russia. Both through Russian loans for his businesses and money laundering for Russian oligarchs. Now that Trump has Musk, Thiel, and the Project 2025 people he isn't as financially dependent on Russia. Now Putin is apparently relying more on threats of assassination. At any rate Trump is still subservient to him as we are seeing now, both with Trump's talk of ending the Ukraine war to Russia's advantage and installing pro-Russian fellow travelers in charge of US intelligence.

Expand full comment
Stuart's avatar

Do you think there are really salacious facts from Trump's youth that could derail him and his agenda now? Suppose it came out that he had had a long affair with Ivanka and that he's the father of her two oldest kids. That's about the worst revelation I can imagine, from Trump's perspective. Would that knowledge make a dent in his base's adulation?

Expand full comment
Lee Peters's avatar

For some it would only increase their admiration. Yeesh.

Expand full comment
Bruce Kelley's avatar

Musk and Trump have a symbiotic relationship. Musk and other oligarchs paid to put him in office and are now flooding their social media platforms with disinformation that is justifying his implementation of more-and-more autocratic policies. We are already at the point where he is testing the waters to see if he can get away with ignoring court orders. As a political expert recently said, when the Executive can decide which court orders to obey and can decide that the Executive's orders are lawful, we are in a dictatorship.

Expand full comment
Ted's avatar

It’s trumps only real business model, licensee deals. He has licensed out his demagoguery and MAGA to Musk to run the show. Trump is there to be cruel and perform Continous firehouse of outrageous stupidity, a distraction while they rob the country blind.

Expand full comment
Shey's avatar

That kid is very big into the schnoz, but apparently was caught on a hot mic saying “You’re not the president and I want you to go away” and “I want you to shut your fucking mouth up” to Trump in the Oval Office during whatever we’re calling that pressconferencedebacle. Priceless.

Expand full comment
leave my name off's avatar

Until reading a comment below, I didn't understand what this comment was getting at....OMG how HILARIOUS!!! His little ears have picked up on what the adults (techies, JD Vance?) have been saying when not in the company of Trump or his other handlers. When most inconvenient, the things that come out of the mouths of babes!

Expand full comment
Shey's avatar

Directly from the mouths of babes, lol.

Expand full comment
Stacy B's avatar

Biggest laugh I’ve had I. A very long time.

Expand full comment
Digispeaker's avatar

I think it's the $250 million he paid to have him elected president.

Expand full comment
Stephen Brady's avatar

tRump is not submissive except with Putin and with Musk. I think they know the Orange MAGAt did something highly illegal…

Expand full comment
bitchybitchybitchy's avatar

Money. Musk has more money then Trump.

Expand full comment
Bern's avatar

Musk is a catspaw for Trump (who doesn't need money anymore – he has a nation).

Expand full comment
Robin Ottawa's avatar

He's past caring. He won and will reap as much as a trillion by corruption.

Expand full comment
Sharon's avatar

Divide and conquer.

Trump's handlers are telling him that Musk is the front guy who's gonna take all the heat when the "small folks" realize they've been played and their own social safety net is gone, not just their neighbors. Robespierre. He was totally it, until he wasn't.

Moneymaker.

Elon's throwing money at Trump making him a real billionaire.

Big Guns.

Musk is happy to use his money to threaten anyone who crosses them in anyway. Primary challenges, hostile buyouts, lawfare, social media attacks.

Expand full comment
Stephen Brady's avatar

I kind of think of Melon Musk as tRump’s Rasputin.

Expand full comment
Andrew Hornick's avatar

Maybe he just likes someone who creates all the chaos he enjoys watching while he eats burgers, dreams up weird things to add or play golf.

Expand full comment
George Patterson's avatar

He doesn't have any hold on DonnyJon. He's doing exactly what DonnyJon wants to do himself, but he hasn't sworn to uphold the Constitution.

Expand full comment
Paul Olmsted's avatar

What isn’t debatable is that Muskrat Economics is an austerity program for us and a huge benefit for him .

Expand full comment
WinstonSmithLondonOceania's avatar

That much is a certainty.

Expand full comment
Ted's avatar

What’s not in 2025?

Musk is using Russel Voight to do the purge while Trump distracts with false, outrageous, crazy talk. Musk is quietly arranging the installation of AI to take over each department as he sees fit, for his advantage in everything.

There are some very smart and caring people at the Tech Policy Press. Everyone should give the link below a read and figure it out, and soon.

https://www.techpolicy.press/anatomy-of-an-ai-coup/

Expand full comment
Ted's avatar

Animal Farm 2.0

The Heritage swine cry, Downsize! Downsize!

Lean and mean—no fat, no ties.

Yet Musk, the stallion, sniffs the air,

Sees a prize just waiting there.

In weeks, the pigs will wire the pen,

AI shall rule instead of men.

No horse to toil, no man to scheme,

Just code to dictate every dream.

From Greenland’s ice to Panama’s sand,

One great farm, one iron hand.

All animals equal? That’s passè

Now AI rules, and none say neigh.

Expand full comment
WinstonSmithLondonOceania's avatar

Muskrat is no stallion, he's a pig, as is Trumpty Dumpty. The only question is, which one is Napoleon and which is Squealer?

Four legs good, two legs better!

Expand full comment
Christian Lutkemeyer's avatar

Trump is sent by God. He is the Orange Highlighter of Corruption that SHOWS US what NOT TO DO. Unfortunately the CINO (Christian in name only) of America do not understand the message, yet.

https://www.djtpresidentiallibrary.com/are-we-ready-for-god-s-intelligence-test

When will they get enlightened?

Expand full comment
Matty's avatar

It is worse than that. The people who already accepted this offer have no official guarantee of their buyouts, and there is reporting that some accounts and payments were already canceled outright without Congressional authority.

Expand full comment
Adam Carey's avatar

Musk believes he can get away with making promises of severance then simply not pay it because HE ALREADY got away with it at Twitter.

Expand full comment
Ted's avatar

Dirty rotten scoundrels

Expand full comment
Omar Canales's avatar

Well, they should’ve known better. I bet those who resigned voted for him.

Expand full comment
GJ Loft ME CA FL IL NE CT MI's avatar

Many of those that resigned were going to quit this year anyway. Some people already have other jobs lined up, so there was no risk in quitting.

Expand full comment
DK Brooklyn's avatar

It’s also very much about getting the data.

Musk is trying to buy OpenAI. AI depends on having data. Connect these dots. The danger is plain to see, but we’re treating things as if they’re not connected.

Some people still call them clowns. So many are ignoring our own warnings that if trump won it will have been the last election.

People still have a wait and see attitude instead of getting a head of the problem.

Expand full comment
Ted's avatar

I think musk wants OpenAI in order to eliminate a competitor. And do what he did to Twitter control the information that people can consume through his filters essentially making it closed AI for all of us this way, the political technologist, the posters and alternative facts campaign, a pretty picture while the house is burning down. And the masses will believe it.

Expand full comment
Joel Bolonick's avatar

I totally agree with ths comment.

Musk and Trump’s routine is actually unbelievably transparent and worthy of trashy dictatorships like Ceauscescu of Romania.

The real tragedy here is that half of the American public, knowing what a criminal and con man Trump was in his first term, chose to reelect him.

Expand full comment
Ted's avatar

Not hiring new ones. The great AI replacement has begun. No one expected it would begin with our federal government.

https://www.techpolicy.press/anatomy-of-an-ai-coup/

Expand full comment
Andy's avatar

Americans are so stupid these obvious lies and manipulations keep working. They just want an excuse to replace people loyal to the country with people loyal to them alone.

Expand full comment
Miles vel Day's avatar

The fact that people who are being brought in or going along with the charade are basically swearing loyalty oaths to Trump and Musk is going to give us both a handy resources and full legal pretext to send everyone involved in this criminal coup to prison for the rest of their lives. Every. Single. One.

They don't want a radicalized center. It's not going to be Obama-time reach-across-the-aisle smiley faces next time. If they ever lose a shred power they're going to lose EVERYTHING.

Honestly I'm ready for the military to just kickstart this shit whenever. I'm checking my watch every day. Once the Constitutional crises start piling up it just may happen.

Expand full comment
User's avatar
Comment deleted
Feb 13
Comment deleted
Expand full comment
User's avatar
Comment deleted
Feb 13
Comment deleted
Expand full comment
Somewhere, Somehow's avatar

AI taking over your writings. I have the same problem.

Expand full comment
User's avatar
Comment removed
Feb 13
Comment removed
Expand full comment
ErisX's avatar

Yup. That's Trump's business model.

Expand full comment
Public Servant's avatar

If only Trump and Musk’s fathers used condoms. My civil service colleagues and I have been collecting evidence of the muskrat’s criminal fraud activity. He is falling for our traps and will end up in jail with the orange felon, where they belong. We are all FBI agents now: https://democracydefender2025.substack.com/p/we-are-all-fbi-agents-now

Expand full comment
Teri's avatar

Oh please make it so!

Expand full comment
Shauna's avatar

Trump and project 2025 IS following the Russia and Hungary PLAYBOOK...but...he didn't factor in the Patriotic American PEOPLE ...... fatal mistake ..... not going to work. It will likely be a fight even if they feign co-operation at some point for a bit.....it is their power and $$$ money vs us...and they will choose themselves - they MUST and we MUST...but we have 341, 145, 670 against 1 - last count

Expand full comment
Linda's avatar

Do you even realize how few that is. I wanna believe but alas I just don't. Two thirds of the population, either by voting orange or by simply not caring enough to bother, want this. All the 50 state capital protests, great, I even participated. They don't even register in the media, local, national, social, none of it. Boycotts, super. Amazon stock went down by something like 1.8%. That's like a rounding error. I mean its like someone moved the decimal point...literally. They have more money than God. I think it's gonna take something pretty substantial, maybe even monumental, to stop this freight train from plunging off the cliff. I mean I'm here for it whatever that is but it's going to have to do better than this.

Expand full comment
ErisX's avatar

I think it's a serious mistake to assume DJT stands alone. He certainly does have company, allies, and hangers-on who will support the Trump admin. At this point our best hope is that the Trump admin gets drowned in a bathtub.

Expand full comment
Mark Czerwinski's avatar

@Shauna -- sounds like you still believe in American Exceptionalism, against all evidence to the contrary

Expand full comment
Shauna's avatar

I don't believe it ..... I KNOW it...I feel it. Trump/Putin tried this out in the wrong Country....And we are only getting started...Yes...it's a huge mountain of deceit. But what is the alternative for us now ? The American People will rise... and cue Pauls music lol "Oh What a Day " nothing worth doing ...well, is usually easy. Our Freedoms since the 1940's were on the backs of the Hero's who died for that Freedom for us. Seems we now need to pick up the baton ... or we could google how bad things really are in Russia or Hungary ?? hint..having Freedom and then have Autocracy ..... will hurt like hell .... I would always bet on the People :) I feel it :)

Expand full comment
Dee Whitman's avatar

Shauna, you're either very naive or you're a Russian troll; if the former, please STOP, because you're harming everyone.

What you "feel" isn't borne out by facts -- verifiable facts, evidence-based facts. Horrifyingly, a lot of Americans are apathetic. Forty years of ruinous GOP economic policies have concentrated massive wealth in very few hands, such that someone like fElon can buy an election and control djt, who needs felon's money to pay off his legal debts and the judgments against him. And for almost 40 years, the GOP has run an effective propaganda machine such that lots of low-info behaviors have swallowed lies (abut who is harming them) and have continued to vote for GOPs, who actually *are* harming them.

If you care at all about American democracy, then stop "feeling" and "believing" and start DOING. Join your local Dem chapter. Join Indivisible and MoveOn, and participate in the actions. Call GOP reps and sens, even if they aren't yours, and tell them you want them to shut down felon's criming NOW. Participate in the 2-28-25 buying blackout. And so on.

Expand full comment
SqueakyRat's avatar

I never heard Captain Kirk put it just that way.

Expand full comment
Teri's avatar

I don’t think he ever had to say please 😁 but I think Picard used the command more than Kirk.

Thank you for the flashback…good memories.

Expand full comment
Matty's avatar

Love this! We ARE all FBI agents now!! Great article. Thanks for sharing.

Expand full comment
ErisX's avatar

One problem with that otherwise good plan: SCOTUS already told us Trump's immune, and Trump can pardon whoever he wants.

Not sure if impeachment would even work. Something else may have to remove him from office.

Expand full comment
Robin Wilson's avatar

Tea?

Expand full comment
Shauna's avatar

Oh...and we will NEED to back up the FBI prior to an attempted roll over to the NEW "KGB or SS" is the plan...a sinister mandate for the notorious Kash Patel....Will we be SHOCKED, surprised ??? Not any longer...LOCK HIM UP ..is where we have to get to...albeit..sounds good over my coffee..they have all the advantages ...for today

Expand full comment
Digispeaker's avatar

Thank you for making me laugh with that first sentence.

Expand full comment
WinstonSmithLondonOceania's avatar

Thank you, thank you, thank you!

Expand full comment
bitchybitchybitchy's avatar

Musk couldn't possibly get a security clearance, with his publicly acknowledged history of ketamine use. Also, Elon, I worked for the DOJ for over 39 years. Our work desktops ( later laptops) were configured to deny access to certain types of websites, and video games were off limits.

So, Elon, you're on a work improvement plan, and if you don't shape up, you're gone- and your booger picking tot is too.

Expand full comment
The Coke Brothers's avatar

Probably take it to state court in NY or CA or somewhere.

Expand full comment
Chris Gay's avatar

Tell us more about this evidence.

Expand full comment
Matt Gregg's avatar

Good work, but don't plan on them in jail. Pardons. Pardons for everyone.

Expand full comment
Jessica Simpson's avatar

Having worked in the Social Security Administration for the years 1973-2008, I can tell you unequivocally we don't have 150 years olds collecting benefit! Decades ago my colleagues were involved with the Centenarian project. This meant personally interviewing 100 years old by sending a field representative to the house, nursing home etc. to determine if the person was alive, and where they were living. We also had another project that matched Medicare rolls with SSA benefit rolls, and Medicaid rolls with the SSI rolls. If there was no activity on one of those records for a period of time, a face to face interview was required. Musk is trolling us. It's shameful we have to waste any time answering trolls.

Expand full comment
Jeff Schroth's avatar

Apparently the super genius and his team of elite coders are so clueless and inexperienced that they don't realize all the birth years showing as "1875" in the SSA data is a commonly used placeholder COBOL programmers use when the birth year is unknown.

Expand full comment
Auros's avatar

Specifically because COBOL uses the ISO 8601 format.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ISO_8601

Every computer date format has a date that it references from. So for instance the Linux time_t format is an absolute time (i.e. you need a time zone to resolve it), which is stored as an integer representing the number of microseconds since Jan 1, 1970 at midnight GMT.

The ISO 8601 date format is referenced against May 20, 1875, the date of the Metre Convention.

Expand full comment
Colleen radigan's avatar

That hilarious and sad at the same time. On a serious note - why isn’t there a blow horn countering every false statement these clowns make.

Expand full comment
Jeremy Kleier's avatar

I'm sure Musk's kiddies are allergic to COBOL...

Expand full comment
leave my name off's avatar

Actually, one of those Muskrats is taking a speed lesson in COBOL.

Expand full comment
Sharon's avatar

OMG! That's funny.

Expand full comment
Seth Hathaway's avatar

COBOL FOR DUMMIES

Expand full comment
Becky's avatar

I’ll send musk the COBOL users guide for windows sitting on my desk.

Expand full comment
Jeffrey's avatar

Thank you for “factually” enlightening us and for your years selfless service!

Expand full comment
CJ in SF's avatar

Yup. Techno-faux genius Musk never heard of data entry errors or computer bugs.

Expand full comment
LarryG's avatar

It's so very disappointing how easy the trolling can be....

Expand full comment
Derelict's avatar

"there are quite a few people in the bureaucracy who have ostensibly a salary of a few hundred thousand dollars, but somehow managed to accrue tens of millions of dollars in net worth while they are in that position"

Musk has a point here. Consider Chief Justice John Roberts. Despite only making a few hundred thousand dollars a year in salary, he's managed to accrue tens of millions of dollars . . . because his wife has been systematically taking bribes from companies with business before the Court. So maybe that's how they made their money.

Or consider Justice Clarence Thomas, who likewise gets a mere pittance in salary, yet has millions accrued . . . by being given "gifts" from billionaires with business before the Court.

I'm sure these are the kinds of cases Musk is talking about. Right?

Expand full comment
Andrew's avatar

Ha - my exact comment but with better examples. Thomas is the poster child for what Musk claims to have found and yet...

Expand full comment
Deb Vitkova's avatar

I wish!

Expand full comment
LaurieOregon's avatar

I've read in other Substacks that Musk is going after government agencies that are or have been investigating him or his companies. Once he fires agency staff, the investigations -and possible fines - disappear.

With Trump-Musk, follow the grievance, follow the money. All the rest is largely theater to distract us.

Expand full comment
Merry Foster's avatar

I've read that too. Specifically about Starlink and how USAID, which paid for the receivers in Ukraine, found that some had made their way into Russia and were investigating. Not only do we need to be our own FBI, we need to be our own CIA as well.

Expand full comment
LaurieOregon's avatar

Merry, I'm glad you had details.

Expand full comment
TomD's avatar

Plus a dose of messianic narcissism.

Expand full comment
Arthur Sanders's avatar

I worked for 25 years at a town hall in Norway, there were 16 000 inhabitants. Of course there was waste, but we worked with auditors and local politicians to find improvements. Nobody could have walked in the door and found any fraud in two days.

Expand full comment
TomD's avatar

I doubt Musk and his band of elves could even describe in a sentence or two what these agencies do and what American interests they were created to meet.

Expand full comment
Matty's avatar

It WASN’T an audit. It was a theft. The orange tool is just too stupid to understand that… yet. Trump will learn the hard way when his own personal information is doxxed to his enemies by Musk’s petulant little teens.

Expand full comment
bitchybitchybitchy's avatar

Thr Inspector General positions were created ro provide an avenue for reporting fraud and waste. The U.S. also has the GAO.

Expand full comment
WinstonSmithLondonOceania's avatar

They could - if they themselves were acting fraudulently.

Expand full comment
Shauna's avatar

fake justifications AND to give to the RICH...where is Robin HOOD ??? I guess they are in the courts daily fighting back..but other hero's will emerge....The Art and Music community hasn't even gotten started yet with motivation and solidarity ..... but it only took Hitler 33 days to overthrow the entire Germain Government and we are day 24..time is of the essence

Expand full comment
ErisX's avatar

Let's hope there are plenty of American HEROES around, we sure need 'em! Hint: don't look to Hakeem for heroism. He can't figure out how to message better.

Expand full comment
WinstonSmithLondonOceania's avatar

It's coming. The courts have already put up a few detours and a few Senate Republicans are beginning to stir. It's growing. When the time comes, it will explode.

Expand full comment
Jill Harsin's avatar

Someone also tried to collect SS in my name a few years ago. I was contacted by the SS administration and the attempted fraud was stopped. The problem is: thanks to DOGE's attacks against the federal workforce and the loss of expertise, this sort of "catch" may not happen in the future.

Expand full comment
Jacob Lehman's avatar

I wonder how much money we'll "save" by not investigating tax cheaters too...

Expand full comment
WinstonSmithLondonOceania's avatar

"We" save nothing. "They" save trillions. That feedback noise you hear is the sound of plutocrats waging class war against the rest of us while screaming "class war" at anyone who points out the obvious fact.

Expand full comment
ErisX's avatar

They better hope that scream can't be heard by those who are 2nd Amendment Rights nuts.

Expand full comment
Becky Daiss's avatar

Pretty sure they (the billionaires, heritage foundation, white nationalists, maga congress etc) have succeeded in their plan to break government, declare government is broken, take over said government, and destroy democracy. Whatever we are living under now, it is not democracy.

Expand full comment
LM's avatar

As PJ O’Rourke once wrote: “The Republicans are the party that says government doesn't work and then they get elected and prove it.” They’ve been doing it for 40+ years!

Expand full comment
ErisX's avatar

Wow, there's a name I haven't seen a long while! Thanks for jogging my memory.

Expand full comment
Jim Monsees's avatar

Becky,

I agree with you, that we have only remnants of our treasured Democracy; although not in the Federal Government but in The Courts, in the hands of Governors, and in the spirit of Woke Democrats (the empathetic ones, not the Karen’s).

The brazenness of the Trump leading edge destruction shows that the democratic hold-outs/Resistance have a monumental fight to preserve Constitutional Democracy.

They must persist in throwing up roadblocks to harass this Trump/Oligarch scheme pending the election midterms. Then, at least Congress can join the Resistance.

Even then, the odds that an Autocracy will be defeated aren’t very good. But it’s worth the risk and effort to try.

Expand full comment
Jim Monsees's avatar

We agree with you about the Courts being key to resisting tyranny.

The major tests will be regarding “unfair deportations”, “FBI Retributions”, “Abrupt Firings of Civil Servants” and “Musky Intrusions into Fed Financial Databases”.

The Trump AG will try every lever Trump has to discourage the Courts.

Expand full comment
Andan Casamajor's avatar

That AG is not off to an auspicious start with the Eric Adams fiasco and publicly announcing that she's "filed charges" against NY state officials, when she actually only filled a civil lawsuit that is likely to crash and burn at the first hearing.

Expand full comment
TomD's avatar

It depends on what happens with the courts.

Expand full comment
Soiltek's avatar

“This space intentionally left blank” is the most hilarious use of the phrase I’ve ever seen! I need to use it to this effect in my legal memos. 🤣 👏

Expand full comment
Bill Hopping's avatar

I found an actual massive waste that could fill the void. get the DOGE kids on it! https://www.npr.org/2025/02/13/g-s1-48571/trump-administration-order-400-million-worth-of-armored-teslas

Expand full comment
Mart's avatar

Thank you for writing this. I found it remarkable that after Musk’s “comprehensive” analysis of waste, he can’t understand what use USAID has for condoms.

Yesterday Trump promised us more examples. Based on what he said I’m going to go out on a limb and predict that they will be more half-truths and lies, this time probably designed to gin up anger over the migrant “crisis”.

We are about to watch the gaslighting like a fugue reaching its crescendo.

Expand full comment
George Carty's avatar

I'd have thought that (for anyone worried about migrant influxes) that condoms for Africa would be a win-win policy, especially as (unlike in almost the entire Global North) desired fertility is considerably lower than actual fertility in many African countries.

Expand full comment
GrrlScientist's avatar

Professor Krugman: this is a prime example of how important it is to learn geography, as well as reading comprehension.

and during that "press conference" in the oval office, trump looked like a sedated zoo animal, merely present for appearanes, to be seen, whilst elon muskrat ranted in front of the cameras and his spoilt brat told trump to "shut TF up" and to "just leave" already. oh, and wiped boogers on trump's desk. it was spectacularly revolting. i hope the salivating press got their cheap clicks.

Expand full comment
Jeffrey's avatar

It’s great to see your “fact” based analysis.

I’d like to make two points regarding Musk’s claim: “there are quite a few people in the bureaucracy who have ostensibly a salary of a few hundred thousand dollars, but somehow managed to accrue tens of millions of dollars in net worth while they are in that position, which is what happened at USAID”

The first point is that I personally know individuals who came from wealthy families with net worths in millions and CHOSE a career in government service, rather than in business, and have loved serving their country.

And, I assume that there are lots of other ways these civil servants may have accumulated wealth - a successful spouse, investing over many years in a stock market that has soared for decades!

And, my second point is how in hell did Musk get access, if it actually exists, to this kind of personal data of Federal Employees, including USAID to make this claim???

Oh, and I guess there’s a third point too. Musk knows thanks to public information, that Senators, including many Republicans, are worth tens of millions - yet he doesn’t claim that they are guilty of fraud or corruption and that’s how they accumulated their wealth…

Finally, to the GOP congresspersons for your silence. You know better. And soon he’ll come for you.

Expand full comment
Michael's avatar

First, the only federal employee earning "a few hundred thousand dollars" is the president with a salary of $400,000. The only people earnings over $300,000 are supreme court justices. The people earning over $200,000 but under $300,000 are the vice president and house speaker along with some doctors, dentists, and SEC examiners. None of these people could be considered bureaucrats.

Second, its weird how Musk throws out a salary of "a few hundred thousand dollars" like it is a pittance. For the great majority of people this would be a huge salary. With this type of salary many people could accumulate millions of dollars by simply investing a large chunk of it in index funds.

https://www.ntu.org/foundation/tax-page/salaries-for-members-of-congress-supreme-court-justices-and-the-president

Expand full comment
Alexander Stewart's avatar

My question is, how does he know the net worth of the individuals working there? For example, I would be surprised if my employer knew what my exact net worth is. They certainly know how much I get paid and how much 401k match I get. But how do they know what the value of my current bank and investing accounts are?

I think the obvious answer is that they wouldn't, if they were just pulling data from where they allowed to have access to. One explanation why they might have more information is that they possibly already have some people singled out and know more about them than they should. But there are plenty of other reasonable examples as to why a government employee might be wealthy (wealthy families, spouses, inheritance, investing, etc..)

It is just a witch hunt, plain and simple, and a particularly insidious one too. Show the common people examples of rich government employees, and therefore they must be defrauding the government. Very much a populist message.

Expand full comment
Leah Sims's avatar

Yes, I thought mainstream reporters were ignoring the significance of the net worth statement. Are they looking at financial disclosure forms for employees? Or are they cross-referencing information about employees with other federal databases, which would include tax returns? That would be consistent with the vacuuming up of data that everyone fears, but which is prohibited by law and recent judicial decisions. Why isn't a reporter asking why Elon Musk is looking at individual finances in such detail and what is the source of his information?

Expand full comment
Essmeier's avatar

"Musk knows thanks to public information, that Senators, including many Republicans, are worth tens of millions - yet he doesn’t claim that they are guilty of fraud or corruption and that’s how they accumulated their wealth…"

Actually, I saw a quote just yesterday from Musk about just such a thing -

https://www.msn.com/en-us/politics/government/elon-musk-questions-congress-members-wealth-where-did-they-get-all-the-money/ar-AA1yULcj

Of course, his list included mostly Democrats...

Expand full comment
Alexander Stewart's avatar

A quote from the article you linked to. Did you read it at all?

"The top 10 traders in 2024 list was made up of six Republicans and four Democrats with five Congress members having returns of more than 100% in 2024."

And trading on insider information is not the same as using public funds or defrauding the government.

Expand full comment
DrBDH's avatar

Trump has a salary of hundreds of thousands and has accrued by grift a wealth of billions (he says). Is Musk attacking Trump?

Expand full comment
Deb Vitkova's avatar

And Silent co-conspirators, most of the Dems in congress

Expand full comment
Jon Zellweger's avatar

I think you are touching on something we need to keep saying, often and everywhere: Musk is running the country, Acting President Musk, And we should refer to trump as POTUSINO (Prez ... IN NAME ONLY). It'll drive 'em all nuts.

Expand full comment
Hannes Jandl's avatar

It is quite plausible for a USAID employee to have a net worth in the 10s of millions based on a $200,000/yr salary. It's not that sinister. USAID employees typically don't pay taxes in the country where they reside, and often get housing allowances. In any case, it is a job where you can save a great deal and then invest that money in real estate and the stock market. So sure, a few canny investments 20 years ago and you might be worth $10 million today. Especially if you bought Tesla stock. Does Musk really have a problem with that? No, he's just grandstanding.

Expand full comment
Leah Sims's avatar

My father-in-law worked for USAID, starting circa 1959. He was no idealist, but had been born dirt poor and between ROTC and working had attended college. He loved the idea of the housing allowance and I think there were hardship bonuses for certain countries. There was nothing to spend money on in some of these countries, no shopping malls, expensive restaurants, etc. He invested 99% of his salary. You could also import things, via the embassy "big pouch", like electronic equipment and a car. When they left a country, they could sell this stuff at a profit. They were also some of the cheapest people I ever met and made every penny count. They did have a substantial net worth while he was still working, considering he and his wife had started with nothing when they married.

Expand full comment
bitchybitchybitchy's avatar

Musk is likely unaware of thrle Thrift Savings Plan. It was created as part of the then new retirement system for federal employees (FERS). Employees contribute a set sum of their salary and thr government matches that sum.

Employees who chose to remain in the old CSRS system could also create TSP's, but did not receive a matching contribution as we had pensions.

If an employee is prudent and than lets their TSP grow, those accounts can provide a generous return.

Expand full comment
Raymond Alldritt's avatar

Examples or data would be nice to see. As a US citizen living in a foreign country I still pay US taxes and taxes in the country I live in. So I would classify your assertion another urban myth unless you can provide some verifiable data.

Expand full comment
Rick Herbst's avatar

Brilliant! Love the “THIS SPACE INTENTIONALLY…”… that got me for a minute because I noticed it (dark background) before my eyes got to reading the paragraph above. Great laugh and an even greater point. Awesome article. Thanks for writing!!

Expand full comment
Karen Rile's avatar

I agree, very clever. Another reason I’m pleased to be reading Paul’s column here and not in the “failing New York Times.”

Expand full comment
bitchybitchybitchy's avatar

"All thr 'news ' we can fit"

Expand full comment
Tina's avatar

I have to agree. Prof Krugman going feral on Substack has been bringing me so much joy in these dark times.

Expand full comment
Matty's avatar

THIS WAS A THEFT! Trump was played for the FOOL he is. Musk stealing our private information is not an “audit”. Teenage CODERS ARE NOT ACCOUNTANTS!

Expand full comment
Sockjam's avatar

Musk already has the information you are so worried about. Social security numbers, bank account numbers, emails. He has the highest security clearances because he has NASA and military contracts for SpaceX and Tesla... We're talking about a guy who built PayPal, Tesla and owns a social media platform! Stop being so naive.

Expand full comment
Matty's avatar

Actually he was denied that clearance. Not sure it’s been approved yet. Far from naive, just nice.

Expand full comment