"This is a very deep analysis, but it makes me think about the bigger picture of American reliability. The US healthcare system is unstable because the politics are unstable. For us, who were abandoned after years of alliance, we know what it feels like when Washington changes its direction and leaves you in the wreckage. Now, the American people are experiencing their own version of this wreckage with Trump II cutting Medicaid and healthcare subsidies. A single-payer system or a public option is definitely the right path, because leaving human lives in the hands of private companies for profit is a disaster. But the real problem is political willpower. If America wants to lead or be a model for the world, it needs to show it can take care of its own people first. Right now, the insurance companies have more power than the voters.
It's shameful what's being done to our former allies. Like many Americans, I look forward to the day when the current administration is behind us, and the many injustices they have inflicted can be corrected.
I'm skeptical of U.S. voters. Americans knew who and what Trump is, yet they put the Golden Grifter in office twice. They'd be in prison for corruption, but it's okay for the Trump family?
Just being opposed to The Don isn't enough. Democrats need to get it together or JD Vance, Marco Rubio or Ron DeSantis might be our next president. The built-in rural bias of the Electoral College is a very high hurdle.
"I am not a member of any organized political party. I am a Democrat" ---Will Rogers
Insurance companies are often blamed. They certainly have a lot to answer for. But they are only part of the machine of the disease management system of the US. We don’t have a healthcare system based upon the extent of chronic disease. 90% of healthcare dollars go towards chronic conditions. Part of this is related to demographic shifts and an aging population. Yet when 60% of American adults have one chronic condition and 40% have two or more.
The issue is that the conversation usually revolves around who pays for healthcare. The real question we should be asking is how do we improve health in the US to reduce the cost of care?
“Disease management”, yes! We are so reactive. We need to look to more prevention and, as you stated, improving health. I think this also means *full body* healthcare. Vision, dental, mental, and (bodily) healthcare should all be included under one umbrella, not parsed out.
I agree. But putting it all under one umbrella is still just a mechanism of allocation - who pays and how. It will be more challenging to hit the leverage points upstream of clinics, hospitals, and ORs.
I think that one way to form political willpower is to send people to look at a standard picture of how a single-payer will work. Then we can avoid a lot of confusion, and more people can agree that we should do it. This animated diagram shows how the money flows, and packs in a lot of other information too. It is preceded by shorter video that explains the diagram symbols:
Under Bismarck, Germany invented universal healthcare in 1883. Today it's a hybrid system that uses public and private insurance. Germany always ranks near the top in quality of care. We don't have to reinvent the wheel, maybe take a serious look at what other countries are doing.
There were always for-profit health insurance companies. They didn't suddenly spring up when Reagan took office. Most major insurers had a medical insurance division.
A major component of the excessive costs of health care in this country that is not routinely discussed is the excessive salaries of the C-Suite members in the hospitals, clinics and health insurance companies compared with those salaries in other countries. Additionally the salaries of medical staff is also excessive in comparison to what the same staff earn in other countries.
I agree that CEOs receive obscene compensation. I good argument for the not-for-profit model in healthcare. Secondary and tertiary providers (CNAs, RNs) are typically not overpaid. It’s the specialty surgeons and “board certified” folk who get paid waaaay more than in other “first world” countries with universal healthcare.
CEOs of nonprofit hospitals and systems also get paid very well. MBAs run nonprofit systems to maximize revenue, not to maximize the health of the community. They do give away money because they are legally required. But they also charge exorbitant prices--$19k for less than a day at the hospital for which my insurer paid $16k and I paid the balance.
Stick the insurance companies who are for profit in there, and that’s another layer we pay that other countries do not. Medicare runs very efficiently and does not require a profits to be paid to anyone. Just expand Medicare. And another good idea is right off middle school expense for Dr who agreed to be primary cares for 10 years for example. They are way underpaid and overworked.
The same happens in higher education. Both healthcare and higher ed are top heavy and full of paper shufflers and bean counters, plus dozens of vice presidents, vice provosts, directors and what have you.
Paul - thanks for the observations. I have deep experience in healthcare including 7 years on the Board of a Medicaid-Medicare duals plan. Net is Medicare for all will not work - it is much more complicated than most think, has potentially-onerous financial cost sharing provisions, and is completely federally run.
Medicaid for all is a much better starting point.
- it covers almost all care - including long term care (which can be adjusted/re-done)
- it is fully integrated
- unlike Medicare which only covers the aged and disabled, Medicaid covers all ages and therefore is built to handle all of us
- it includes state cost sharing - which makes it more palatable to federal legislators.
I have been advocating a buy-in to Medicaid for a decade or more now as a public option, largely in Krugman's comments sections here and at NYT.
We need a public option that allows for a buy-in to Medicaid at a percentage of a persons income. Seniors should be able to choose this instead of Medicare if they want, as well.
Medicare is VERY expensive if you are a low income senior and perhaps a buy-in program could eliminate the Medicaid estate recovery pitfalls.
Medicaid seems in practice to be the lower-quality component of a two-tiered healthcare system. Inflicting it on the middle class may actually be a step toward improving it, but it will be ugly.
How to relieve employers from providing employee healthcare without in the process making a giant transfer of wealth to their shareholders is a major challenge.
Medicare+Medicaid usually means Medicaid covers all that co-insurance stuff, as well as Part D (at either much lower rates than private insurance or not at all). If we get Medicare for all, I think we should still have a everything is free tier at that 138% above the poverty line and below, and have something like a $20 co-pay for everyone else, so that the health care system isn't taxed with overutilization.
Thanks for the note Elizabeth Medi-Cal in California is certainly simpler. States often have varying eligibility requirements and benefit provisions. Suffice it to say that Mississippi’s Medicaid program looks nothing like California’s.
That's exactly the problem with Medicaid, Joe. Even just the 10% state buy in leads to vastly different experiences between the on average industrious and wealthy California vs. poorer Missississippi. We already share resources so much at the federal level, so that yes, on average people in states like California subsidize people in the states like Mississippi, because at the end of the day we're one country and one people. And at the end of the day, having a single uniform standard of health care for all Americans gives Americans risk reduction and security and the most freedom, including the freedom to move around the country (for example, to a lower cost of living state like Mississippi).
Access to care is a hurdle for Medicaid in many states, and, to dive deeper, that can translate into quality but isn’t necessarily a given. Its current, fundamental problem is that participation varies greatly by state which in turn affects whether or not providers are willing to accept it. Presumably, that would be addressed as part of any package. The administrative side of Medicaid is also slow moving, so hopefully that would be addressed as well.
Agree HCinKC - Medicaid recipients in Mississippi are far worse off than those in Massachusetts. Revising Medicaid laws to require uniform services at a reasonable level would go a long way to resolving that - as long as the funding is there as well.
Each state has the leeway to set its own Medicaid funding levels and also has wide discretion on coverage parameters; the national government kicks in a set percentage of what each state commits to, varying by income levels (poor states get higher %'s). Both funding and coverage under Medicaid varies widely from state to state. As a result, payments for services vary widely from state to state. A Medicaid nursing home in TX gets MUCH less daily reimbursement under Medicaid than one in MA. So, of course, service quality varies A LOT. Red states want low or no income taxes and do not care much about the level of services provided for the poor under Medicaid. Universal Medicaid standards would totally undermine "state's rights."
I agree. Medicare for old people (I’m old, and traditional Medicare works okay for me), and Medicaid for everyone else. Just change the name to Americare. Then Americare can absorb Medicare.
And Medicare does not pay all costs. It only pays 80% of "reasonable" costs, which often means the patient ends up paying more than 20% of the costs, which can still be crippling for many. That's also why many people on Medicare purchase Medicare supplemental insurance (like Medicare Advantage). So you pay a premium for Medicare and another premium for the supplement. Medicaid for all eliminates both of those issues
So just so people aren't confused, Medicare supplemental is Medigap (previously Part G). Medicare Advantage is what restricts which doctors you can see or which hospitals you can visit. They're the ones with prior authorizations (well, until the One Big Beautiful Bill Act added prior authorizations to traditional Medicare).
So part A and part B have different co-insurance structures. Part A is the hospital side of things, while Part B is the physician side of things (for performing a procedure to a doctor's visit). Part B has a standard co-insurance of about 20%, but the physician's fee in my experience is never so crazy. I've never seen it be over $1000 and almost always less than $500, usually for an inpatient or outpatient procedure. So 20% of $500 is $100. An office visit is usually $40-200, an so 20% is $8-40.
While Part A does have a sizeable deductible, most of the health care after that does not have a co-pay unless you're dealing with a really, really long hospital stay (you're really sick). So that procedure that the physician got paid $500 for (let's say a cardiac catheterization and angioplasty) for example, the hospital's part in the procedure, which is probably in the tens of thousands of dollars, won't cost more than that large deductible.
And Medigap's supposed to help with those costs.
And if you have Medicare + Medicaid, all that co-pay, deductible stuff goes out the window.
Thanks for the note Ralph. It’s likely you were referring to a Medicare Advantage program which has a lot more flexibility regarding authorization of healthcare.
fabled committee of blind people describing the part of the elephant they can reach out and touch. The whole system is vastly complex and varied, from state to state and even from region to region.
It could however Medicare's current population is overwhelmingly >65. Medicare plans - Medicare Advantage is just one - are based on that population, as are Medicare benefits. Thus any adoption of MFA (Medicare For All) would require significant changes to systems, clinical guidelines, provider evaluation and on and on.
I've experienced Kaiser, employer-sponsored private, total insurance, and CA Medicaid/Partnership. In a few years I will pay to leave CA Medicaid/Partnership despite being low income because despite finding it to be an easy-to-use system with few major barriers to care, I am spooked by the estate recovery provision. I will probably go to Kaiser, even tho services in my immediate area are limited.
Fwiw, my unmarried partner with an insurance background thinks that consumer protections/ malpractice is the biggest barrier to universal healthcare in the U.S. in terms of how it drives costs in unsustainable ways. I don't know enough to have an opinion there, tho I do note the cost differences between partially privatized Medicare and Medicaid.
There is certainly something in your partner's perspective however I strongly believe the for-profit motive - even in not-for-profits - is a far more powerful driver. I do not see the tort system as a significant obstacle to universal coverage; I do see Citizens United as a major roadblock.
We should approach reforming our healthcare industry as more than just providing health insurance. We must push to pass legislation that not only provides a single-payer insurance system, but also provides:
- Research grants for more medical research. Research into pharmaceuticals, treatments, and better delivery systems. MAGA has broken scientific research and we must correct this quickly.
- Educational grants to create more doctors, nurses, other healthcare support positions, and medical researchers. Lets make education for medical positions free or near to free. If we want universal healthcare there must be the healthcare workers to meet that need.
- Grants to state & local governments to expand access by building more rural hospitals and health clinics. Lets make this a clear win for rural America.
We must address healthcare from all angles by passing legislation that sets up the USA to not just catch up to other comparable nations, but sets a framework for the USA to be a true leader in healthcare.
Also, why do we have to wait for 2029? If a progressive party can win in 2026, then hold Vance & Trump in fear of impeachment and push for reform now. We are tired of waiting. Democrats always push for small iterative compromised changes. Democrats fail to realize that their inability to push for real reform is the reason why MAGA has been able to capture the "populist" messaging in elections.
One type of a public option would be to allow seniors who not quite 65 (as well as those who are) the option to buy into Medicare at a "percentage of income," as well as the not quite poor enough the option to buy into Medicaid. Both done at a percentage of income.
A senior person should be able to choose to buy in to either program at a percentage of income and those younger, can chose to buy into Medicaid.
The reason I suggest this is because in my view, Medicare is way to expensive for low income seniors, and if you are poor enough to qualify for Medicaid and also over 55, it is fraught with some anxiety producing estate recovery laws, as well, so, a buy-in at a percentage of income with no recovery laws would be a better option for low income seniors.
Those very well to do folks may decide that a percentage of income is more than they pay now, thus, the first to make the transition into either buy-in may be on the lower end of the income scale, but face it, they need the most help.
This also gets rid of the income cliff issue for Medicaid where some may be afraid of working too much overtime because they could have to switch to another type of plan. With this, if they go over an income cap, they simply buy-in at the percentage for the amount over the cap.
I am a senior and Medicare is way to expensive and does not over as much as Medicaid. I would opt into a Medicaid buy-in instead if available or would love it if the payment was based on income.
Unless and until we can agree, as a country, that healthcare is a basic human right and not a privilege, it doesn't make a difference what system we argue about. I fear that day may never come.
Maybe someday Americans will learn the difference between good intentions like 'healthcare is a basic human right' and incentives - the reality of how costs are determined and who pays them. But as of now, the US system is uniquely bad in cost control. We have a supply-side system which basically first decides how much health care it wants, then throws money at the providers, requiring them to squabble among themselves for a share of the largesse, uses the uniquely abuse-prone 'cost-plus' pricing for reimbursement, relies on a broken market to set prices for specialist care and many other highly-trained positions .....and on and on.....
Just posted today on 18 and OUT! how our comprehensive Constitutional amendment can help solve the healthcare crisis by requiring members of Congress to be on the same healthcare plans available to common citizens. See 18andout.substack.com for details.
Although I have no disagreement with Krugman’s analysis and suggestions, there is one important variable that these non-medical articles always forget - the contribution of the patient to his or her own health. The lousy US health data must take this factor into consideration. At the current time, 2026, over 50% of the US adult population is obese. I’m not talking about a few pesky pounds that a person wants to lose. The increase in the rate of obesity mirrors the worsening of health outcomes data, and health care cost. Obese patients develop type II diabetes, which leads to coronary artery disease and kidney failure, all necessitating costly treatments. Add into this the destruction of the public health structure (largely by Kennedy), the decrease in vaccine utilization, and other idiotic health “advice” on the internet that patients find more credible than the advice of their physicians), and you have the hot mess described here. One writer asked us to remember the flamboyant salaries of hospital administrators, and probably health insurance providers, which is a point well taken. When I was working in hospitals providing newborn critical care, the joke among we physicians was that it was easy to distinguish the administrators from the docs. We looked like hell, and they were wandering around in Gucci suits. Now here’s a good thought experiment: the US underwent a government-directed public health program in the late 60s and early 70s - a smoking cessation program, largely brought into being by Dr Koop, the surgeon general at the time, which was unbelievably successful. Why can’t the government (after Kennedy is blessedly gone) undergo a similar project, to encourage better eating practices, better exercise practices, and cessation of drug use?
But it doesn’t have to be. Of course, when you have SNAP/WIC benefits under siege and “food deserts”, it costs more - money and time. It’s ridiculous that I can drive (*drive* being an operative word, too) to at least a dozen grocery stores within a 5 mile radius, but 15 miles away there is nothing but a convenience store.
I also have to say that, to a degree, this is a lie we have been sold. My personal experience has been that my grocery bill is much higher if I buy more convenience foods (and meat). Perhaps that varies by region though. I know what I pay for my groceries in the Midwest is quite different from my in-laws on the east coast.
I am so pleased to read your endorsement of single payer health insurance for the US, based on its excellent performance in other nations. Lower costs and longer lives can happen here.
That said, I respectfully offer several refinements, in the interest of realizing the single payer gains.
(a) A “single payer” is, and must be, singular. The current "single payers" that you describe (i.e., Medicare and Medicaid) differ in critical ways from a true single payer as implemented in other nations. For example, even though Medicare covers almost all seniors, traditional fee-for-service Medicare is complicated by coinsurance (Medi-Gap) and Medicare Advantage has a central role for private insurers. For both, cost-sharing is high. These factors introduce complexity for patients, versus simplicity in any real single payer system. And for providers, even Traditional Medicare is just one payer among many, contributing to a billing-and-insurance-related administrative burden of fully 10% of revenue.
(b) A public option would provide some efficiency (eg no profits) versus private insurance. However, if it worked reasonably well, it would select for enrollees most needing health care – that is, more expensive than average. Assuming that costs need to be covered by premiums, this would mean higher premiums, amplifying selection effects, and so on in a downward spiral. Private insurers would exacerbate this, offering plans to encourage sicker patients to migrate to the public option. If this public option were part of Medicare, patients would face its cost-sharing challenges. Meantime, providers would continue to suffer under the complexity of a multi-payer system. Thus, the hoped-for transition to full single payer would serve only to prove (falsely) that “single payer can’t work in the US”. Perhaps it would survive as one more option in the underperforming US health insurance mess.
(c) Let’s learn the proper lessons from single payer nations: To simultaneously achieve equity & efficiency means adopting one insurance plan for everyone, with identical benefits, payments, and formulary. And minimal cost-sharing. In other words, let’s save 10% of costs via administrative streamlining and use those savings to cover everyone for all needed health care.
Those of us advocating over 30 years for single payer welcome you to this just cause.
Sincerely, James G. Kahn MD MPH, University of California San Francisco
Great comment (as are so many on this excellent piece by Krugman). All I want (ha!) and think you and many other do, too, is for Healthcare For All to become reality. By which I mean simplified, efficient, effective, available, and so on. The mishmash we have is absurd. Simplicity is absolutely critical. And doable. IMHO, for-profit health insurance companies are immoral
Oops (Candace here, wasn't finished) ..... Meant to say, the idea of for-profit health insurance strikes me as amoral at the very least. The cost is staggering. Not just the $$$, but the cost in time - researching, being selected, being dropped, the in-or-out-of-network baloney, ad infinitum. --- Heard a great podcast the other - won't ID as don't want to misconstrue their message - but it had to do with health care (among other areas of life) reform (single-payer being a given) and included bringing down our national debt in the process. The point of the talk was this COULD be done but the likelihood is moot due to the absence (in current-day America) of a CRITICAL MASS OF ADULTS IN THE ROOM capable of sound thinking and sensible problem-solving skills. Made sense to me, sad to say. Hope we can find a way.
I’m 74. You do realize that the ACA is not healthcare it’s a gift to the insurance corporations. Based on ROMNEYCARE. Google is the ACA based on Romneycare. Then get back to me about how hard the Democrats are trying to push M4A. Haha 🤣
Yep, Romney passed a similar plan in Massachusetts when he was governor and it worked very, very well. The problem? Or do you dislike it because it came from a Republican, so who cares if it worked or not.
And that gift was to people like me and millions of others who have guaranteed access to health insurance because of the ACA. It is imperfect. All systems are. But to deny the huge amount of good it is doing is blindness.
And by the by, of all pathways to universal care, M4A is distinctly the worst. It doesn't do what the best systems in the world do and it doesn't even do what other single payer systems do to be sustainable.
Obama won his first nomination, the one that led to the ACA, despite the DNC. Hillary Clinton was supposed to be the Democratic nominee in 2008. The DNC lost their own primary. It's the last time the DNC has held an honest primary for President.
Although some have made wild conspiracy claims when things did not go their way (some Bernie folks) even resorting to violence although much milder levels of violence than MAGA (but also death threats) the fact check sites looked into it deeply and found the DNC conspiracy claims not to be remotely true.
I know it is frustrating when a person's favorite does not win, but that does not = rigged.
The truth is that on a notional level, the public is simply not as liberal as they are in the big blue states and once one goes into primaries in more centrally located states, people like Warren and Bernie start to lose in national contests even in Dem primaries. The reason is that on a national level they are not as popular overall.
Bernie lost by 11 states and over 3 million votes. It was not even close.
When people yell "rigged" they divide the Dem party and the Dem loses the election.
Divided political parties always lose esp when the wings run a 3rd party candidate or were one, this happened to all below.
Al Gore, Hillary, Teddy Roosevelt, Bush Sr for term 2, due to Ross Perot.
Are you implying that Bernie was robbed of presidential nominations by the DNC? If so, I'm not buying it. I would suggest that the primary reasons Bernie lost were because 1) he had serious limitations as a candidate, 2) his campaigns were not very well run, and 3) he positioned himself as a factional leader rather than the leader of the entire party.
That strategy might have worked if the progressives had a clear majority of support within the Democratic party, but they simply didn't.
So a suggestion: If you would like a true progressive to win the Democratic presidential nomination, how about focusing on finding the right candidate and building the campaign infrastructure needed to win rather than engaging in blame games?
He wasn't robbed of anything. He wasn't as popular as her.
He never should have been allowed to run in the Democratic primary anyway because he is the first to tell you he isn't a Democrat. He is a "Democratic Socialist". They bent over backwards to let him in the process. Enough of all the faux outrage fed to the liberals by right wing OpSec.
The pragmatic analysis and decision the Dems face is just that- whether going “progressive” will help or hinder electability - This moderate thinks it would most likely help!
How do you figure that? I live in one of the bluest states in the country so I can vote for Mickey Mouse and I don’t need or want your permission. Go VBNMW.
LBJ was the first president I voted for and the Great Society programs profoundly changed my life, my parents’ lives, the lives of my grandmother, aunts, uncles, great-aunts and uncle, all for the better. Medicare alone secured an independent life for the elderly, money for college for my sister and me, and a secure retirement for my parents.
Simply offer people medicare and show them how their increased taxes would be LOWER than what they quietly pay through their payroll systems. In fact they would pay substantially less.
Be aware that Medicare in its current form would be a step down for folks with decent private insurance. For example, it has gaps in coverage (such as no dental and vision) and in its base form has no cap on out-of-pocket expenses. You really need to add a supplemental plan, and so-called "Advantage" plans basically amount to a giveaway to private insurance companies.
In addition, Medicare's low reimbursement rates and onerous administrative provisions can result in some providers refusing to take Medicare patients.
My wife is a mental health counselor and does not take Medicare patients because of provisions that include claw back reimbursements that can go back forever (private insurance companies generally have a statute of limitations). As a solo provider who brings in only a modest amount of income, that's not a risk she is willing to take. She is hardly the only one.
In reality the company that offers the health care benefit is the one who gets the tax break instead of the employee.
Why do you think employers hate the idea that the government would provide health care to everyone and they wouldn't have to have to pay HR professionals to deal with their workers insurance? It's free money from the government for them!
Many of us rational people think that every Democrat, in Congress and running for Congress, should be campaigning for some or all of this. The great failure of Obamacare, not allowing the states to set up a public option, was due to the opposition of a Democrat, Joe Lieberman. We 𝑐𝑎𝑛𝑛𝑜𝑡 have opposition like that the next time we have a chance to move forward.
Could states do this on a state by state basis? Would it be possible to require medical providers to accept the public option as part of being licensed to operate?
"This is a very deep analysis, but it makes me think about the bigger picture of American reliability. The US healthcare system is unstable because the politics are unstable. For us, who were abandoned after years of alliance, we know what it feels like when Washington changes its direction and leaves you in the wreckage. Now, the American people are experiencing their own version of this wreckage with Trump II cutting Medicaid and healthcare subsidies. A single-payer system or a public option is definitely the right path, because leaving human lives in the hands of private companies for profit is a disaster. But the real problem is political willpower. If America wants to lead or be a model for the world, it needs to show it can take care of its own people first. Right now, the insurance companies have more power than the voters.
It's shameful what's being done to our former allies. Like many Americans, I look forward to the day when the current administration is behind us, and the many injustices they have inflicted can be corrected.
I'm skeptical of U.S. voters. Americans knew who and what Trump is, yet they put the Golden Grifter in office twice. They'd be in prison for corruption, but it's okay for the Trump family?
Just being opposed to The Don isn't enough. Democrats need to get it together or JD Vance, Marco Rubio or Ron DeSantis might be our next president. The built-in rural bias of the Electoral College is a very high hurdle.
"I am not a member of any organized political party. I am a Democrat" ---Will Rogers
Insurance companies are often blamed. They certainly have a lot to answer for. But they are only part of the machine of the disease management system of the US. We don’t have a healthcare system based upon the extent of chronic disease. 90% of healthcare dollars go towards chronic conditions. Part of this is related to demographic shifts and an aging population. Yet when 60% of American adults have one chronic condition and 40% have two or more.
The issue is that the conversation usually revolves around who pays for healthcare. The real question we should be asking is how do we improve health in the US to reduce the cost of care?
“Disease management”, yes! We are so reactive. We need to look to more prevention and, as you stated, improving health. I think this also means *full body* healthcare. Vision, dental, mental, and (bodily) healthcare should all be included under one umbrella, not parsed out.
I agree. But putting it all under one umbrella is still just a mechanism of allocation - who pays and how. It will be more challenging to hit the leverage points upstream of clinics, hospitals, and ORs.
I think that one way to form political willpower is to send people to look at a standard picture of how a single-payer will work. Then we can avoid a lot of confusion, and more people can agree that we should do it. This animated diagram shows how the money flows, and packs in a lot of other information too. It is preceded by shorter video that explains the diagram symbols:
https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLT-vY3f9uw3AwU-OdsiSOdK1EtAE2rz3J
That is only because the Democrats and the Republican refuse to work for the good of the American people.
“Hey, AI, please respond to every Paul Krugman post, making it all about ME. After all, clearly nobody really wants to hear about anything else.”
Under Bismarck, Germany invented universal healthcare in 1883. Today it's a hybrid system that uses public and private insurance. Germany always ranks near the top in quality of care. We don't have to reinvent the wheel, maybe take a serious look at what other countries are doing.
There were always for-profit health insurance companies. They didn't suddenly spring up when Reagan took office. Most major insurers had a medical insurance division.
Obviously. I was addressing the statement that all plans were non-profit.
A major component of the excessive costs of health care in this country that is not routinely discussed is the excessive salaries of the C-Suite members in the hospitals, clinics and health insurance companies compared with those salaries in other countries. Additionally the salaries of medical staff is also excessive in comparison to what the same staff earn in other countries.
I agree that CEOs receive obscene compensation. I good argument for the not-for-profit model in healthcare. Secondary and tertiary providers (CNAs, RNs) are typically not overpaid. It’s the specialty surgeons and “board certified” folk who get paid waaaay more than in other “first world” countries with universal healthcare.
I was witness to a cardiac surgeon tuning down a pay package of a million and a half.
CEOs of nonprofit hospitals and systems also get paid very well. MBAs run nonprofit systems to maximize revenue, not to maximize the health of the community. They do give away money because they are legally required. But they also charge exorbitant prices--$19k for less than a day at the hospital for which my insurer paid $16k and I paid the balance.
Stick the insurance companies who are for profit in there, and that’s another layer we pay that other countries do not. Medicare runs very efficiently and does not require a profits to be paid to anyone. Just expand Medicare. And another good idea is right off middle school expense for Dr who agreed to be primary cares for 10 years for example. They are way underpaid and overworked.
And get private equity out! They are ruining access, cost, and quality for patients and causing burnout and disillusionment amongst providers.
🙌
Which in turn helps make medical school expensive
I think Cuba has some of the best doctors in the world, and their medical education is free.
The same happens in higher education. Both healthcare and higher ed are top heavy and full of paper shufflers and bean counters, plus dozens of vice presidents, vice provosts, directors and what have you.
Paul - thanks for the observations. I have deep experience in healthcare including 7 years on the Board of a Medicaid-Medicare duals plan. Net is Medicare for all will not work - it is much more complicated than most think, has potentially-onerous financial cost sharing provisions, and is completely federally run.
Medicaid for all is a much better starting point.
- it covers almost all care - including long term care (which can be adjusted/re-done)
- it is fully integrated
- unlike Medicare which only covers the aged and disabled, Medicaid covers all ages and therefore is built to handle all of us
- it includes state cost sharing - which makes it more palatable to federal legislators.
more here - https://joepaduda.substack.com/p/the-case-for-medicaid-for-all?utm_source=publication-search
Agree 100%
I have been advocating a buy-in to Medicaid for a decade or more now as a public option, largely in Krugman's comments sections here and at NYT.
We need a public option that allows for a buy-in to Medicaid at a percentage of a persons income. Seniors should be able to choose this instead of Medicare if they want, as well.
Medicare is VERY expensive if you are a low income senior and perhaps a buy-in program could eliminate the Medicaid estate recovery pitfalls.
Medicare did not in the past cost so much as it does now.
Excellent point P&J. The buy-in should include some amount for everyone - a cost certainly makes folks more aware of the value.
be well Joe
Medicaid seems in practice to be the lower-quality component of a two-tiered healthcare system. Inflicting it on the middle class may actually be a step toward improving it, but it will be ugly.
How to relieve employers from providing employee healthcare without in the process making a giant transfer of wealth to their shareholders is a major challenge.
My brother has been on both Medicaid (Medical because we're in CA) and Medicare, and says Medicaid is much better.
Medicare+Medicaid usually means Medicaid covers all that co-insurance stuff, as well as Part D (at either much lower rates than private insurance or not at all). If we get Medicare for all, I think we should still have a everything is free tier at that 138% above the poverty line and below, and have something like a $20 co-pay for everyone else, so that the health care system isn't taxed with overutilization.
Thanks for the note Elizabeth Medi-Cal in California is certainly simpler. States often have varying eligibility requirements and benefit provisions. Suffice it to say that Mississippi’s Medicaid program looks nothing like California’s.
Be well, Joe
That's exactly the problem with Medicaid, Joe. Even just the 10% state buy in leads to vastly different experiences between the on average industrious and wealthy California vs. poorer Missississippi. We already share resources so much at the federal level, so that yes, on average people in states like California subsidize people in the states like Mississippi, because at the end of the day we're one country and one people. And at the end of the day, having a single uniform standard of health care for all Americans gives Americans risk reduction and security and the most freedom, including the freedom to move around the country (for example, to a lower cost of living state like Mississippi).
Access to care is a hurdle for Medicaid in many states, and, to dive deeper, that can translate into quality but isn’t necessarily a given. Its current, fundamental problem is that participation varies greatly by state which in turn affects whether or not providers are willing to accept it. Presumably, that would be addressed as part of any package. The administrative side of Medicaid is also slow moving, so hopefully that would be addressed as well.
Agree HCinKC - Medicaid recipients in Mississippi are far worse off than those in Massachusetts. Revising Medicaid laws to require uniform services at a reasonable level would go a long way to resolving that - as long as the funding is there as well.
be well Joe
Each state has the leeway to set its own Medicaid funding levels and also has wide discretion on coverage parameters; the national government kicks in a set percentage of what each state commits to, varying by income levels (poor states get higher %'s). Both funding and coverage under Medicaid varies widely from state to state. As a result, payments for services vary widely from state to state. A Medicaid nursing home in TX gets MUCH less daily reimbursement under Medicaid than one in MA. So, of course, service quality varies A LOT. Red states want low or no income taxes and do not care much about the level of services provided for the poor under Medicaid. Universal Medicaid standards would totally undermine "state's rights."
Healthcare for all Americans would never DENY COVERAGE FOR ANYONE but I am the jerk.
I agree. Medicare for old people (I’m old, and traditional Medicare works okay for me), and Medicaid for everyone else. Just change the name to Americare. Then Americare can absorb Medicare.
And Medicare does not pay all costs. It only pays 80% of "reasonable" costs, which often means the patient ends up paying more than 20% of the costs, which can still be crippling for many. That's also why many people on Medicare purchase Medicare supplemental insurance (like Medicare Advantage). So you pay a premium for Medicare and another premium for the supplement. Medicaid for all eliminates both of those issues
So just so people aren't confused, Medicare supplemental is Medigap (previously Part G). Medicare Advantage is what restricts which doctors you can see or which hospitals you can visit. They're the ones with prior authorizations (well, until the One Big Beautiful Bill Act added prior authorizations to traditional Medicare).
So part A and part B have different co-insurance structures. Part A is the hospital side of things, while Part B is the physician side of things (for performing a procedure to a doctor's visit). Part B has a standard co-insurance of about 20%, but the physician's fee in my experience is never so crazy. I've never seen it be over $1000 and almost always less than $500, usually for an inpatient or outpatient procedure. So 20% of $500 is $100. An office visit is usually $40-200, an so 20% is $8-40.
While Part A does have a sizeable deductible, most of the health care after that does not have a co-pay unless you're dealing with a really, really long hospital stay (you're really sick). So that procedure that the physician got paid $500 for (let's say a cardiac catheterization and angioplasty) for example, the hospital's part in the procedure, which is probably in the tens of thousands of dollars, won't cost more than that large deductible.
And Medigap's supposed to help with those costs.
And if you have Medicare + Medicaid, all that co-pay, deductible stuff goes out the window.
Thanks for the note Sashank- excellent summary - thanks for sharing your expertise.
be well Joe
Husband and me are paying about $ 1000 every month for Medicare B, Medicare D, gap plan G, dental insurance.
And even then they deny coverage. Bastards
Thanks for the note Ralph. It’s likely you were referring to a Medicare Advantage program which has a lot more flexibility regarding authorization of healthcare.
Be well Joe
This is kind of like the
fabled committee of blind people describing the part of the elephant they can reach out and touch. The whole system is vastly complex and varied, from state to state and even from region to region.
Generally, speaking for Medicaid, yes for Medicare no. However, there are quite a bit of similarities in Medicaid programs across the states.
Be well Joe
Wouldn't Medicare for All cover all ages?
It could however Medicare's current population is overwhelmingly >65. Medicare plans - Medicare Advantage is just one - are based on that population, as are Medicare benefits. Thus any adoption of MFA (Medicare For All) would require significant changes to systems, clinical guidelines, provider evaluation and on and on.
be well Joe
Interesting.
I've experienced Kaiser, employer-sponsored private, total insurance, and CA Medicaid/Partnership. In a few years I will pay to leave CA Medicaid/Partnership despite being low income because despite finding it to be an easy-to-use system with few major barriers to care, I am spooked by the estate recovery provision. I will probably go to Kaiser, even tho services in my immediate area are limited.
Fwiw, my unmarried partner with an insurance background thinks that consumer protections/ malpractice is the biggest barrier to universal healthcare in the U.S. in terms of how it drives costs in unsustainable ways. I don't know enough to have an opinion there, tho I do note the cost differences between partially privatized Medicare and Medicaid.
thanks for the note LM.
There is certainly something in your partner's perspective however I strongly believe the for-profit motive - even in not-for-profits - is a far more powerful driver. I do not see the tort system as a significant obstacle to universal coverage; I do see Citizens United as a major roadblock.
be well Joe
We should approach reforming our healthcare industry as more than just providing health insurance. We must push to pass legislation that not only provides a single-payer insurance system, but also provides:
- Research grants for more medical research. Research into pharmaceuticals, treatments, and better delivery systems. MAGA has broken scientific research and we must correct this quickly.
- Educational grants to create more doctors, nurses, other healthcare support positions, and medical researchers. Lets make education for medical positions free or near to free. If we want universal healthcare there must be the healthcare workers to meet that need.
- Grants to state & local governments to expand access by building more rural hospitals and health clinics. Lets make this a clear win for rural America.
We must address healthcare from all angles by passing legislation that sets up the USA to not just catch up to other comparable nations, but sets a framework for the USA to be a true leader in healthcare.
Also, why do we have to wait for 2029? If a progressive party can win in 2026, then hold Vance & Trump in fear of impeachment and push for reform now. We are tired of waiting. Democrats always push for small iterative compromised changes. Democrats fail to realize that their inability to push for real reform is the reason why MAGA has been able to capture the "populist" messaging in elections.
Thanks for unlocking.
One type of a public option would be to allow seniors who not quite 65 (as well as those who are) the option to buy into Medicare at a "percentage of income," as well as the not quite poor enough the option to buy into Medicaid. Both done at a percentage of income.
A senior person should be able to choose to buy in to either program at a percentage of income and those younger, can chose to buy into Medicaid.
The reason I suggest this is because in my view, Medicare is way to expensive for low income seniors, and if you are poor enough to qualify for Medicaid and also over 55, it is fraught with some anxiety producing estate recovery laws, as well, so, a buy-in at a percentage of income with no recovery laws would be a better option for low income seniors.
Those very well to do folks may decide that a percentage of income is more than they pay now, thus, the first to make the transition into either buy-in may be on the lower end of the income scale, but face it, they need the most help.
This also gets rid of the income cliff issue for Medicaid where some may be afraid of working too much overtime because they could have to switch to another type of plan. With this, if they go over an income cap, they simply buy-in at the percentage for the amount over the cap.
I am a senior and Medicare is way to expensive and does not over as much as Medicaid. I would opt into a Medicaid buy-in instead if available or would love it if the payment was based on income.
Unless and until we can agree, as a country, that healthcare is a basic human right and not a privilege, it doesn't make a difference what system we argue about. I fear that day may never come.
Maybe someday Americans will learn the difference between good intentions like 'healthcare is a basic human right' and incentives - the reality of how costs are determined and who pays them. But as of now, the US system is uniquely bad in cost control. We have a supply-side system which basically first decides how much health care it wants, then throws money at the providers, requiring them to squabble among themselves for a share of the largesse, uses the uniquely abuse-prone 'cost-plus' pricing for reimbursement, relies on a broken market to set prices for specialist care and many other highly-trained positions .....and on and on.....
The phrase “…to be promote the general welfare…” certainly makes universal access to health care seem Constitutional.
Just posted today on 18 and OUT! how our comprehensive Constitutional amendment can help solve the healthcare crisis by requiring members of Congress to be on the same healthcare plans available to common citizens. See 18andout.substack.com for details.
Although I have no disagreement with Krugman’s analysis and suggestions, there is one important variable that these non-medical articles always forget - the contribution of the patient to his or her own health. The lousy US health data must take this factor into consideration. At the current time, 2026, over 50% of the US adult population is obese. I’m not talking about a few pesky pounds that a person wants to lose. The increase in the rate of obesity mirrors the worsening of health outcomes data, and health care cost. Obese patients develop type II diabetes, which leads to coronary artery disease and kidney failure, all necessitating costly treatments. Add into this the destruction of the public health structure (largely by Kennedy), the decrease in vaccine utilization, and other idiotic health “advice” on the internet that patients find more credible than the advice of their physicians), and you have the hot mess described here. One writer asked us to remember the flamboyant salaries of hospital administrators, and probably health insurance providers, which is a point well taken. When I was working in hospitals providing newborn critical care, the joke among we physicians was that it was easy to distinguish the administrators from the docs. We looked like hell, and they were wandering around in Gucci suits. Now here’s a good thought experiment: the US underwent a government-directed public health program in the late 60s and early 70s - a smoking cessation program, largely brought into being by Dr Koop, the surgeon general at the time, which was unbelievably successful. Why can’t the government (after Kennedy is blessedly gone) undergo a similar project, to encourage better eating practices, better exercise practices, and cessation of drug use?
Not smoking saves money. Healthy eating is expensive.
But it doesn’t have to be. Of course, when you have SNAP/WIC benefits under siege and “food deserts”, it costs more - money and time. It’s ridiculous that I can drive (*drive* being an operative word, too) to at least a dozen grocery stores within a 5 mile radius, but 15 miles away there is nothing but a convenience store.
I also have to say that, to a degree, this is a lie we have been sold. My personal experience has been that my grocery bill is much higher if I buy more convenience foods (and meat). Perhaps that varies by region though. I know what I pay for my groceries in the Midwest is quite different from my in-laws on the east coast.
Prof. Krugman:
I am so pleased to read your endorsement of single payer health insurance for the US, based on its excellent performance in other nations. Lower costs and longer lives can happen here.
That said, I respectfully offer several refinements, in the interest of realizing the single payer gains.
(a) A “single payer” is, and must be, singular. The current "single payers" that you describe (i.e., Medicare and Medicaid) differ in critical ways from a true single payer as implemented in other nations. For example, even though Medicare covers almost all seniors, traditional fee-for-service Medicare is complicated by coinsurance (Medi-Gap) and Medicare Advantage has a central role for private insurers. For both, cost-sharing is high. These factors introduce complexity for patients, versus simplicity in any real single payer system. And for providers, even Traditional Medicare is just one payer among many, contributing to a billing-and-insurance-related administrative burden of fully 10% of revenue.
(b) A public option would provide some efficiency (eg no profits) versus private insurance. However, if it worked reasonably well, it would select for enrollees most needing health care – that is, more expensive than average. Assuming that costs need to be covered by premiums, this would mean higher premiums, amplifying selection effects, and so on in a downward spiral. Private insurers would exacerbate this, offering plans to encourage sicker patients to migrate to the public option. If this public option were part of Medicare, patients would face its cost-sharing challenges. Meantime, providers would continue to suffer under the complexity of a multi-payer system. Thus, the hoped-for transition to full single payer would serve only to prove (falsely) that “single payer can’t work in the US”. Perhaps it would survive as one more option in the underperforming US health insurance mess.
(c) Let’s learn the proper lessons from single payer nations: To simultaneously achieve equity & efficiency means adopting one insurance plan for everyone, with identical benefits, payments, and formulary. And minimal cost-sharing. In other words, let’s save 10% of costs via administrative streamlining and use those savings to cover everyone for all needed health care.
Those of us advocating over 30 years for single payer welcome you to this just cause.
Sincerely, James G. Kahn MD MPH, University of California San Francisco
Great comment (as are so many on this excellent piece by Krugman). All I want (ha!) and think you and many other do, too, is for Healthcare For All to become reality. By which I mean simplified, efficient, effective, available, and so on. The mishmash we have is absurd. Simplicity is absolutely critical. And doable. IMHO, for-profit health insurance companies are immoral
Oops (Candace here, wasn't finished) ..... Meant to say, the idea of for-profit health insurance strikes me as amoral at the very least. The cost is staggering. Not just the $$$, but the cost in time - researching, being selected, being dropped, the in-or-out-of-network baloney, ad infinitum. --- Heard a great podcast the other - won't ID as don't want to misconstrue their message - but it had to do with health care (among other areas of life) reform (single-payer being a given) and included bringing down our national debt in the process. The point of the talk was this COULD be done but the likelihood is moot due to the absence (in current-day America) of a CRITICAL MASS OF ADULTS IN THE ROOM capable of sound thinking and sensible problem-solving skills. Made sense to me, sad to say. Hope we can find a way.
Amen!!
The DNC will never allow the Democrats to run on Healthcare for All.
You have to be kidding. Are you too young to remember Obama or both Clintons or literally every other Democratic candidate since FDR?
Democrats are the party of universal access to affordable high quality health care.
I’m 74. You do realize that the ACA is not healthcare it’s a gift to the insurance corporations. Based on ROMNEYCARE. Google is the ACA based on Romneycare. Then get back to me about how hard the Democrats are trying to push M4A. Haha 🤣
Yep, Romney passed a similar plan in Massachusetts when he was governor and it worked very, very well. The problem? Or do you dislike it because it came from a Republican, so who cares if it worked or not.
And that gift was to people like me and millions of others who have guaranteed access to health insurance because of the ACA. It is imperfect. All systems are. But to deny the huge amount of good it is doing is blindness.
And by the by, of all pathways to universal care, M4A is distinctly the worst. It doesn't do what the best systems in the world do and it doesn't even do what other single payer systems do to be sustainable.
You are AGAINST M4A?????blocked
The Democrats held the Senate, the House and the Presidency.
They controlled everything yet they chose Romneycare over M4A. Great talk. VBNMW
Obama won his first nomination, the one that led to the ACA, despite the DNC. Hillary Clinton was supposed to be the Democratic nominee in 2008. The DNC lost their own primary. It's the last time the DNC has held an honest primary for President.
Why would you come to that conclusion?
Although some have made wild conspiracy claims when things did not go their way (some Bernie folks) even resorting to violence although much milder levels of violence than MAGA (but also death threats) the fact check sites looked into it deeply and found the DNC conspiracy claims not to be remotely true.
https://www.politifact.com/article/2016/may/19/claims-bernie-sanders-supporters-fraud-and-miscond/
I know it is frustrating when a person's favorite does not win, but that does not = rigged.
The truth is that on a notional level, the public is simply not as liberal as they are in the big blue states and once one goes into primaries in more centrally located states, people like Warren and Bernie start to lose in national contests even in Dem primaries. The reason is that on a national level they are not as popular overall.
Bernie lost by 11 states and over 3 million votes. It was not even close.
When people yell "rigged" they divide the Dem party and the Dem loses the election.
Divided political parties always lose esp when the wings run a 3rd party candidate or were one, this happened to all below.
Al Gore, Hillary, Teddy Roosevelt, Bush Sr for term 2, due to Ross Perot.
Are you implying that Bernie was robbed of presidential nominations by the DNC? If so, I'm not buying it. I would suggest that the primary reasons Bernie lost were because 1) he had serious limitations as a candidate, 2) his campaigns were not very well run, and 3) he positioned himself as a factional leader rather than the leader of the entire party.
That strategy might have worked if the progressives had a clear majority of support within the Democratic party, but they simply didn't.
So a suggestion: If you would like a true progressive to win the Democratic presidential nomination, how about focusing on finding the right candidate and building the campaign infrastructure needed to win rather than engaging in blame games?
BS
He wasn't robbed of anything. He wasn't as popular as her.
He never should have been allowed to run in the Democratic primary anyway because he is the first to tell you he isn't a Democrat. He is a "Democratic Socialist". They bent over backwards to let him in the process. Enough of all the faux outrage fed to the liberals by right wing OpSec.
Most but not all. Enough sided with private insurance to nix a public Obamacare option
The pragmatic analysis and decision the Dems face is just that- whether going “progressive” will help or hinder electability - This moderate thinks it would most likely help!
Been voting since McGovern and the Democrats have done nothing to improve my life. No Healthcare for All Americans = no vote.
And with that no vote you get Trump or his ilk.
How do you figure that? I live in one of the bluest states in the country so I can vote for Mickey Mouse and I don’t need or want your permission. Go VBNMW.
LBJ was the first president I voted for and the Great Society programs profoundly changed my life, my parents’ lives, the lives of my grandmother, aunts, uncles, great-aunts and uncle, all for the better. Medicare alone secured an independent life for the elderly, money for college for my sister and me, and a secure retirement for my parents.
Glad to see someone appreciates it!
Gave it away: and repubs have done less. ACA is quite popular now and repubs all opposed it.
Why is it popular? It’s crap. Imagine if we had HEALTHCARE FOR ALL AMERICANS
Just like Mexico, China, Cuba, the entire EU, Saudi Arabia, Canada, shall I keep going????
The patron saint Luigi Nicholas Mangione:
Simply offer people medicare and show them how their increased taxes would be LOWER than what they quietly pay through their payroll systems. In fact they would pay substantially less.
Be aware that Medicare in its current form would be a step down for folks with decent private insurance. For example, it has gaps in coverage (such as no dental and vision) and in its base form has no cap on out-of-pocket expenses. You really need to add a supplemental plan, and so-called "Advantage" plans basically amount to a giveaway to private insurance companies.
In addition, Medicare's low reimbursement rates and onerous administrative provisions can result in some providers refusing to take Medicare patients.
Medicare has onerous administrative provisions? Get lost
My wife is a mental health counselor and does not take Medicare patients because of provisions that include claw back reimbursements that can go back forever (private insurance companies generally have a statute of limitations). As a solo provider who brings in only a modest amount of income, that's not a risk she is willing to take. She is hardly the only one.
Sp you're not willing to take medicare because you need to bill more.
Exactly.
In reality the company that offers the health care benefit is the one who gets the tax break instead of the employee.
Why do you think employers hate the idea that the government would provide health care to everyone and they wouldn't have to have to pay HR professionals to deal with their workers insurance? It's free money from the government for them!
It's a total scam.
Many of us rational people think that every Democrat, in Congress and running for Congress, should be campaigning for some or all of this. The great failure of Obamacare, not allowing the states to set up a public option, was due to the opposition of a Democrat, Joe Lieberman. We 𝑐𝑎𝑛𝑛𝑜𝑡 have opposition like that the next time we have a chance to move forward.
I couldn't agree more about Lieberman - and now we have another grandstanding horse's ass in Fetterman - who knows how many more after the mid-terms..
Thanks for the Unlock, Dr Krugman
Hello Paul Krugman... Very Interesting Post.. The Swiss, and German Models work very well as well...
Anybody else ever noticed that in many charts showing negative divergences, the divergences begin a little after Reagan became president?
(e.g., wealth gap, real wages, share of economic benefits, ...)
..and the true awakening of the Christian Nationalist horde.
Could states do this on a state by state basis? Would it be possible to require medical providers to accept the public option as part of being licensed to operate?