Erica Chenoweth illuminates the value of nonviolent resistance in societal conflicts | Harvard Kennedy School
The following is an excerpt about overconfidence in elections.
“People tend to think the way we create change is through elections, and the result is an overconfidence in elections,” she says. “During election cycles, people divert their energies away from community organization and mobilization in a way that makes it hard to sustain a mode of extra-institutional struggle.”
“One challenge to organization, especially in the Western world, Chenoweth says, is that progressive movements full of freethinkers tend to be fragmented and often internally contentious.
Participants in right-wing movements, meanwhile, are easier to organize because they tend to be more ideologically oriented to following authority.
“In emergencies, people in left-leaning or progressive movements can agree on the problem, so progressive movements tend to rally around a key moment or an emergency,” she says. “But this means they are often reacting to crises rather than taking the initiative or proposing a consensus-based solution to the problem.”
Complicating things further, she says, there is often less agreement in democracies about what exactly constitutes a crisis, and the energy around mobilization for change gets pushed into election cycles.”
From the Peaceful Solution:
Please: Resist. Stop cooperating. Stop spending. Stop the fascist takeover.
Thank you for restacking, and sharing, to help Spread the Word!
For more information on Economic Warfare, please visit my profile page.
Simple slogans have worked great for GOP because a lot of people do not have time to think deeply or look up information on topics. However everybody know what they are unhappy about; so a good one liner can tap right into that. We need to use the same tactics against GOP and the fascists.
Restore America Again (RAA - RAA - RAA).
This should be the overarching non-specific slogan. It means different things to different people. However, that is a feature not a bug. Don't talk about what or how you would Restore America Again. Simply state something everybody can agree is wrong - then state "Restore America Again". Here are some samples of one line statements that many would agree is a problem:
1. We have become a country run by the billionaires and just for the benefit of the billionaires.
2. Health care has become much to expensive because rich CEOs are milking the system without a care for common peoples health.
3. In order to cut taxes for rich people, they have driven the national debt to over $40 trillion, forcing interest rates so high nobody can afford a decent place to live.
4. If you are making your money by sucking billions out of us all, you pay a lower tax rate than regular hard working people earning a salary.
5. Corporate profits are way up because we have allowed monopolies to drive up prices with few rules or enforcement of rules we do have.
6. China is laughing at us as we drive up our own prices with tariff taxes and wars we can neither afford nor win.
7. GOP used to care about conservative values, now its all about no-bids contracts as a payback to those who finance their election or pay them under the table.
8. GOP has lost its way and need a huge loss in November to wake up and get back to its roots.
Our Democratic Party got distracted from our FDR Progressive roots. And those roots in my view are what we should be focused long term on getting back to.
But your list there is all about what’s wrong with the Republican party. And hanging that skunk around their necks is a good plan for this election—making it all about Trump’s and Maga’s complete and total FAILURE.
That said, the reason they were even able to gain enough political capital to control all branches of government, one can argue, is the fault of the Democratic Party’s failure to inspire the voting public.
The longterm focus needs to be rebuilding—not only our country the R’s are in the process of tearing to pieces— the foundation of the Democratic Party itself. Our progressive roots are with FDR and those values we once defined ourselves by is what needs to be restored in mind, body and most importantly spirit.
The R Party (GOP) has been fascist light for a hundred years, now having morphed into full blown kleptocratic despotic. But the corporate, and billionaire class (for lack of a better word) and along with regular folks who’ve propped them up, are arguably as American as any Democrat. And that’s the thing. The R party needs to be shown the door but the Democratic Party needs to be rejuvenated back to its FDR progressive inspirational mode on steroids to govern this 21st Century America. Sounds complex but it’s really not.
I agree that a party has to have policies and goals for developing society. However, in the context of winning elections that has been a weakness for the Democratic Party. When you talk about obvious wrongs, everybody agree - start talking about how exactly it should be fixed and the agreement ends. I think Democrats need to hammer at all the wrongs, but not make any openings for internal fights or external attacks, by giving specifics about how to fix it. GOP doesn't even have a party platform.
So, this is essentially “open forum” day. In that spirit, I wanted to share Hannah Arendt’s analysis regarding how totalitarian movements decimated two illusions of democratic countries. The first illusion is that individuals in the electoral majority are actively involved in their own governance and committed to a political party. However, an electoral residue (think MAGA), when sufficiently energized by some charismatic, anti-system demagogue, can function as the majority in a democratically ruled country and elect officials who then proceed to destroy the democratic process. The second illusion is that these “politically alienated masses,” whom Arendt labeled “the mob,” did not matter, merely existing as a peripheral political phenomenon.
What we are witnessing in real time here in the states is an unfolding of Arendt’s rather brilliant analysis. Have a great weekend, everyone!
Yesterday, Trump threatened the Fed saying if they don't lower interest rates, he will cut off trade with countries who the U.S. has a trade deficit with. That would cause shortages, raise prices and result in a global recession. Where's the tin foil hat? Better make that a straightjacket.
Amidst all the unavoidable (and truthful!) gloom in your”take” on Trump is the satisfyingly ridiculous image of him in a “tinfoil straightjacket” with a matching hat…! Thanks
A thought-provoking paragraph from Michelle Goldberg's reflection on Gloria Steinem and the current negative influence of social media:
"This dynamic has proved deeply destructive to feminism. Social media’s rage-based economy led contemporary feminism to rip itself apart internally with ever-escalating purity tests. At the same time, it fueled the rise of the manosphere, where enterprising creators learned they could make their names both channeling and exacerbating their audience’s resentments. The algorithms built to keep people attached to their devices are inimical to social progress and a terrible substitute for human connection. A workable strategy to escape from the dystopia these algorithms have helped create can be built only outside of them."
Thanks for the gift link! Excellent piece. Chock full of insights and observations.
“We are ruled by a thuggish cabal of cartoon misogynists.” (Not necessarily insightful, but a great line.)
“We have no way of knowing if we’re living through a momentary backlash to the causes she championed or a new age of barbarism that will stamp out even more of the freedoms she helped win. But the bleakness of our time makes her example more important than ever. She didn’t vanquish crude sexism, but she was part of a movement that made it marginal, at least for a while. If it was done before, it can be done again.”
The entire piece is quotable! Or people could just read it. 🤣
Gloria Steinam, who worked directly for the CIA from 1958 to 1962, who rose to prominence because her brand of "feminism" is compatible with the system, in contrast to those with accurate anti-capitalist and anti-imperialist analysis, who said that women supporting Bernie in 2016 were just looking for boyfriends. Why do some people rise to prominence and others remain obscure, in a world where the capitalists own the means of communication?
C’mon man. The claim about Steinem being a covert agent of the CIA is specious and undermines your credibility. She had a minor position there early in her career and she apologized profusely for the comment about Bernie and boys … which was said on the Bill Maher program and may have been a gesture of sarcasm. She was very funny in general. Gloria had brains and beauty, refuting the popular notion that women adopted feminism because they weren’t attractive enough for men.
I never said she was a covert agent. She was an overt agent. And sure, the comment about Bernie on Maher seems to be a joke, but the meaning it imported was still the same. Her function was still the same. This is how the world operates in capitalism, for they own the means of control and it's not always obvious. They work by creating "compatible opposition" that seems to be critical but is not denagerous to them, which takes space from those who would be dangerous to them (and rightly so).
"The Role: Steinem served as the director, organizing non-communist American and Western students to attend Soviet-sponsored World Youth Festivals in places like Vienna and Helsinki.
The Goal: The objective of the program was to counter Soviet propaganda during the Cold War by presenting a democratic, non-communist perspective.
Steinem's Response: When the funding was publicly exposed in 1967, Steinem acknowledged and defended her involvement, describing the agency's indirect support at the time as liberal, nonviolent, and honorable.
It wasn't just her explicit time serving the CIA directly but the rest of her career as well, what she represented and what it accopmlished toward removing economic class analysis from the topics considered important in the realm of feminism. It's a long-time general trend of the whole public sphere in the US, because of course capitalists want to preserve their undue economic status and they own the means of knowledge production and media, so they use it to make sure that relevant analysis against the system of class servitude never float to the top naturally as they would in an unbiased media culture.
I'm not all that young, and I can recognize that it may be a humorous echo but still she backed Clinton and was against Sanders, which shows that her economic positioning is fully capitalist and not even as progressive as Bernie, which is the point. The weaponizing of identity politics to overshadow the class issue would be in full display here. Because Hillary is a woman and it would have been the first woman president, that would outweigh the fact of her being a full-on capitalist and imperialist hawk agains the potential for at leasrt moving in a slightly progressive direction with Sanders.
As for "how thin your veneer is" what's that mean? Do you think I am trying to hide the fact that I fully stand with the working people of the world and against the system of class slavery we're in?
In return for your gift link, here’s one from The Atlantic. A revised essay from Steinem’s forthcoming memoir. https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/2026/09/everything-we-do-matters/688514/?gift=w7_m2RN97tMsT527p4a2LSsOieICwFryT0xdI0MHl-U In it she offers a needed perspective on then and now, even though now seems bleak. We’ve gained far more than we’ve lost. She also reflects on the hidden lives of children and their parents—the dysfunction and violence being more prevalent than anyone cares to admit. Normal is far more dysfunctional than many of us let on.
Hannah Arendt serves as justification for US capitalism and imperialism by making critiques that gloss over the undemocratic nature of the US both internal and external policies while focusing on countries like the USSR and other non-obedient countries, and by acting as if the US ever was a democracy except for certain exceptions, which now applies to Trump, as if this is an exceptional thing and allows people to pretend that the US was a better democracy before him, ignoring the basic fact of the servitude of the whole working class to the capitalists, and the extreme imperialism done by the US for over a century.
'Day off' in times when many of us would love to cry 'give me a break?!'. The constant flood of utter chaos from the Administration has become a struggle to absorb, let alone sensibly interpret. Perhaps we could all use a day off.
Well deserved! Just chill. Make it a weekend!
Overconfidence in Elections
Erica Chenoweth illuminates the value of nonviolent resistance in societal conflicts | Harvard Kennedy School
The following is an excerpt about overconfidence in elections.
“People tend to think the way we create change is through elections, and the result is an overconfidence in elections,” she says. “During election cycles, people divert their energies away from community organization and mobilization in a way that makes it hard to sustain a mode of extra-institutional struggle.”
“One challenge to organization, especially in the Western world, Chenoweth says, is that progressive movements full of freethinkers tend to be fragmented and often internally contentious.
Participants in right-wing movements, meanwhile, are easier to organize because they tend to be more ideologically oriented to following authority.
“In emergencies, people in left-leaning or progressive movements can agree on the problem, so progressive movements tend to rally around a key moment or an emergency,” she says. “But this means they are often reacting to crises rather than taking the initiative or proposing a consensus-based solution to the problem.”
Complicating things further, she says, there is often less agreement in democracies about what exactly constitutes a crisis, and the energy around mobilization for change gets pushed into election cycles.”
From the Peaceful Solution:
Please: Resist. Stop cooperating. Stop spending. Stop the fascist takeover.
Thank you for restacking, and sharing, to help Spread the Word!
For more information on Economic Warfare, please visit my profile page.
Simple slogans have worked great for GOP because a lot of people do not have time to think deeply or look up information on topics. However everybody know what they are unhappy about; so a good one liner can tap right into that. We need to use the same tactics against GOP and the fascists.
Restore America Again (RAA - RAA - RAA).
This should be the overarching non-specific slogan. It means different things to different people. However, that is a feature not a bug. Don't talk about what or how you would Restore America Again. Simply state something everybody can agree is wrong - then state "Restore America Again". Here are some samples of one line statements that many would agree is a problem:
1. We have become a country run by the billionaires and just for the benefit of the billionaires.
2. Health care has become much to expensive because rich CEOs are milking the system without a care for common peoples health.
3. In order to cut taxes for rich people, they have driven the national debt to over $40 trillion, forcing interest rates so high nobody can afford a decent place to live.
4. If you are making your money by sucking billions out of us all, you pay a lower tax rate than regular hard working people earning a salary.
5. Corporate profits are way up because we have allowed monopolies to drive up prices with few rules or enforcement of rules we do have.
6. China is laughing at us as we drive up our own prices with tariff taxes and wars we can neither afford nor win.
7. GOP used to care about conservative values, now its all about no-bids contracts as a payback to those who finance their election or pay them under the table.
8. GOP has lost its way and need a huge loss in November to wake up and get back to its roots.
Our Democratic Party got distracted from our FDR Progressive roots. And those roots in my view are what we should be focused long term on getting back to.
But your list there is all about what’s wrong with the Republican party. And hanging that skunk around their necks is a good plan for this election—making it all about Trump’s and Maga’s complete and total FAILURE.
That said, the reason they were even able to gain enough political capital to control all branches of government, one can argue, is the fault of the Democratic Party’s failure to inspire the voting public.
The longterm focus needs to be rebuilding—not only our country the R’s are in the process of tearing to pieces— the foundation of the Democratic Party itself. Our progressive roots are with FDR and those values we once defined ourselves by is what needs to be restored in mind, body and most importantly spirit.
The R Party (GOP) has been fascist light for a hundred years, now having morphed into full blown kleptocratic despotic. But the corporate, and billionaire class (for lack of a better word) and along with regular folks who’ve propped them up, are arguably as American as any Democrat. And that’s the thing. The R party needs to be shown the door but the Democratic Party needs to be rejuvenated back to its FDR progressive inspirational mode on steroids to govern this 21st Century America. Sounds complex but it’s really not.
I agree that a party has to have policies and goals for developing society. However, in the context of winning elections that has been a weakness for the Democratic Party. When you talk about obvious wrongs, everybody agree - start talking about how exactly it should be fixed and the agreement ends. I think Democrats need to hammer at all the wrongs, but not make any openings for internal fights or external attacks, by giving specifics about how to fix it. GOP doesn't even have a party platform.
Haha, I was just going to write the same :)
Sharon, good one! and I’d say, join a campaign of your choice, and give your best !
Good. Rest up.
So, this is essentially “open forum” day. In that spirit, I wanted to share Hannah Arendt’s analysis regarding how totalitarian movements decimated two illusions of democratic countries. The first illusion is that individuals in the electoral majority are actively involved in their own governance and committed to a political party. However, an electoral residue (think MAGA), when sufficiently energized by some charismatic, anti-system demagogue, can function as the majority in a democratically ruled country and elect officials who then proceed to destroy the democratic process. The second illusion is that these “politically alienated masses,” whom Arendt labeled “the mob,” did not matter, merely existing as a peripheral political phenomenon.
What we are witnessing in real time here in the states is an unfolding of Arendt’s rather brilliant analysis. Have a great weekend, everyone!
History doesn't repeat, but it rhymes—and the song isn't pretty.
Yesterday, Trump threatened the Fed saying if they don't lower interest rates, he will cut off trade with countries who the U.S. has a trade deficit with. That would cause shortages, raise prices and result in a global recession. Where's the tin foil hat? Better make that a straightjacket.
https://www.nytimes.com/2026/09/04/business/economy/trump-trade-threats-fed-rate-cuts.html?unlocked_article_code=1.-1A.riXZ.Ha62_B9pxTmY&smid=url-share
Amidst all the unavoidable (and truthful!) gloom in your”take” on Trump is the satisfyingly ridiculous image of him in a “tinfoil straightjacket” with a matching hat…! Thanks
She was brilliant. And your quote is amazing.
Hi Pam. Yes, she really was. I continue to be impressed on how prescient she was on many issues. And thank you for your kind comment.
A thought-provoking paragraph from Michelle Goldberg's reflection on Gloria Steinem and the current negative influence of social media:
"This dynamic has proved deeply destructive to feminism. Social media’s rage-based economy led contemporary feminism to rip itself apart internally with ever-escalating purity tests. At the same time, it fueled the rise of the manosphere, where enterprising creators learned they could make their names both channeling and exacerbating their audience’s resentments. The algorithms built to keep people attached to their devices are inimical to social progress and a terrible substitute for human connection. A workable strategy to escape from the dystopia these algorithms have helped create can be built only outside of them."
https://www.nytimes.com/2026/09/04/opinion/gloria-steinem-feminism.html?unlocked_article_code=1.-1A.rr5Q.qGrk3MG_kz41&smid=url-share
Thanks for the gift link! Excellent piece. Chock full of insights and observations.
“We are ruled by a thuggish cabal of cartoon misogynists.” (Not necessarily insightful, but a great line.)
“We have no way of knowing if we’re living through a momentary backlash to the causes she championed or a new age of barbarism that will stamp out even more of the freedoms she helped win. But the bleakness of our time makes her example more important than ever. She didn’t vanquish crude sexism, but she was part of a movement that made it marginal, at least for a while. If it was done before, it can be done again.”
The entire piece is quotable! Or people could just read it. 🤣
Gloria Steinam, who worked directly for the CIA from 1958 to 1962, who rose to prominence because her brand of "feminism" is compatible with the system, in contrast to those with accurate anti-capitalist and anti-imperialist analysis, who said that women supporting Bernie in 2016 were just looking for boyfriends. Why do some people rise to prominence and others remain obscure, in a world where the capitalists own the means of communication?
C’mon man. The claim about Steinem being a covert agent of the CIA is specious and undermines your credibility. She had a minor position there early in her career and she apologized profusely for the comment about Bernie and boys … which was said on the Bill Maher program and may have been a gesture of sarcasm. She was very funny in general. Gloria had brains and beauty, refuting the popular notion that women adopted feminism because they weren’t attractive enough for men.
I never said she was a covert agent. She was an overt agent. And sure, the comment about Bernie on Maher seems to be a joke, but the meaning it imported was still the same. Her function was still the same. This is how the world operates in capitalism, for they own the means of control and it's not always obvious. They work by creating "compatible opposition" that seems to be critical but is not denagerous to them, which takes space from those who would be dangerous to them (and rightly so).
Not sure how this incriminates Steinem.
"The Role: Steinem served as the director, organizing non-communist American and Western students to attend Soviet-sponsored World Youth Festivals in places like Vienna and Helsinki.
The Goal: The objective of the program was to counter Soviet propaganda during the Cold War by presenting a democratic, non-communist perspective.
Steinem's Response: When the funding was publicly exposed in 1967, Steinem acknowledged and defended her involvement, describing the agency's indirect support at the time as liberal, nonviolent, and honorable.
It wasn't just her explicit time serving the CIA directly but the rest of her career as well, what she represented and what it accopmlished toward removing economic class analysis from the topics considered important in the realm of feminism. It's a long-time general trend of the whole public sphere in the US, because of course capitalists want to preserve their undue economic status and they own the means of knowledge production and media, so they use it to make sure that relevant analysis against the system of class servitude never float to the top naturally as they would in an unbiased media culture.
I'm not all that young, and I can recognize that it may be a humorous echo but still she backed Clinton and was against Sanders, which shows that her economic positioning is fully capitalist and not even as progressive as Bernie, which is the point. The weaponizing of identity politics to overshadow the class issue would be in full display here. Because Hillary is a woman and it would have been the first woman president, that would outweigh the fact of her being a full-on capitalist and imperialist hawk agains the potential for at leasrt moving in a slightly progressive direction with Sanders.
As for "how thin your veneer is" what's that mean? Do you think I am trying to hide the fact that I fully stand with the working people of the world and against the system of class slavery we're in?
In return for your gift link, here’s one from The Atlantic. A revised essay from Steinem’s forthcoming memoir. https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/2026/09/everything-we-do-matters/688514/?gift=w7_m2RN97tMsT527p4a2LSsOieICwFryT0xdI0MHl-U In it she offers a needed perspective on then and now, even though now seems bleak. We’ve gained far more than we’ve lost. She also reflects on the hidden lives of children and their parents—the dysfunction and violence being more prevalent than anyone cares to admit. Normal is far more dysfunctional than many of us let on.
Hannah Arendt serves as justification for US capitalism and imperialism by making critiques that gloss over the undemocratic nature of the US both internal and external policies while focusing on countries like the USSR and other non-obedient countries, and by acting as if the US ever was a democracy except for certain exceptions, which now applies to Trump, as if this is an exceptional thing and allows people to pretend that the US was a better democracy before him, ignoring the basic fact of the servitude of the whole working class to the capitalists, and the extreme imperialism done by the US for over a century.
Enjoy your day off. You deserve it. Plus I don't want to think today.
Glad to hear it. The airplane oxygen mask is a cliché for a reason: self care allows us to help others.
'Day off' in times when many of us would love to cry 'give me a break?!'. The constant flood of utter chaos from the Administration has become a struggle to absorb, let alone sensibly interpret. Perhaps we could all use a day off.
Enjoy, we need you refreshed and ready to go !! Hope you really do relax!
Please take what you need!
Take care of yourself.
Enjoy a day off.
From your typewriter to God's ear, Paul. Keep up the good fight.
Have a great Labor Day weekend. Well deserved to recharge.
Good idea Paul. Need to recharge as needed to keep on going.👏
Enjoy the holiday. Let's hope that Labor will start getting their fair share.
Well deserved.
I so appreciate your blog and your need for an occasional rest. Enjoy your away!